Are Solar-Plus-Battery Systems Coming to a Neighborhood Near You?
SolarCity thinks batteries will be critical to the widespread use of solar, but for now very few residential customers have the chance to try them
Solar-plus-battery systems that combine photovoltaic(PV) Generation of electricity directly from sunlight. A photovoltaic cell has no moving parts; electrons are energized by sunlight and result in current flow. panels and lithium-ion batteries are helping a number of commercial electricity customers cut their power bills, but any widespread spillover to the residential side of the market looks to be some time away.
SolarCity, the country's top residential installer, provides solar-plus-battery service to roughly 300 California homeowners, and while the company sees opportunities for expansion into other parts of the country in the future, there’s no fixed timetable for getting there.
SunPower would say only that it is piloting an integrated residential solar and battery system in California and Australia, but declined to offer any details. GBAGreenBuildingAdvisor.com couldn't turn up any other installers with similar systems.
Lead-acid batteries have been around for a while
Photovoltaic panels coupled with batteries are, of course, nothing new. Rural homesteaders began installing off-the-grid systems a generation ago, either because they were too far from the grid for a conventional hookup or because they preferred to live independently.
So what’s different now? One thing is the type of battery — new systems incorporate lithium-ion cells developed for the fledgling electric vehicle industry, not the lead-acid batteries used in older off-the-grid installations. Another difference is that today’s solar-plus-battery installations are grid-tied, not stand-alone.
Changing battery technology is key. Lithium-ion batteries have more “energy density” than lead-acid batteries, last longer, and require no maintenance. They’re also expensive, but a recent report by the Rocky Mountain Institute predicts electricity storage will get much cheaper as battery production increases to meet the needs of the electric vehicle industry. Tesla Motors, for example, hopes to open a $5 billion factory to produce lithium-ion batteries for its line of cars by 2020. The Wall Street Journal reports the new Tesla factory when operating will produce more batteries than all of the world’s factories turn out today.
Batteries are mainly for backing up the grid
In older off-grid solar installations, PVPhotovoltaics. Generation of electricity directly from sunlight. A photovoltaic (PV) cell has no moving parts; electrons are energized by sunlight and result in current flow. panels charged batteries that could then be used to power lights, appliances, and the like at night or during cloudy weather. But in SolarCity’s residential systems, the lithium-ion batteries are used only when grid power goes out, sort of like a high-tech gas generator.
The batteries, which are the size of small refrigerators, contain dozens or hundreds of lithium-ion cells. They are designed only to power critical electrical devices for a number of hours while the grid is down.
Eric Carlson, SolarCity’s senior director for grid integration, said the batteries have a capacity of 10 kilowatt-hours, so they could handle a load of 5 kilowatts for two hours before running down. Just how long 10 kWh would go is, of course, completely up to what devices homeowners decide to use. But Carlson said it’s enough energy to run an Energy StarLabeling system sponsored by the Environmental Protection Agency and the US Department of Energy for labeling the most energy-efficient products on the market; applies to a wide range of products, from computers and office equipment to refrigerators and air conditioners. refrigerator for a week without any additional solar charging.
Batteries are typically mounted on a wall in the garage near the system’s inverterDevice for converting direct-current (DC) electricity into the alternating-current (AC) form required for most home uses; necessary if home-generated electricity is to be fed into the electric grid through net-metering arrangements. so they don’t take up any floor space. That’s one advantage of lithium-ion cells — they’re compact enough to make that possible.
The Tesla batteries have a 10-year warranty, although Carlson expects they will last longer than that, and because they are sealed they’re maintenance-free.
These batteries are not for sale
SolarCity began offering the battery option to some California customers in 2012 following research and development that began in 2009 with a state-funded grant. At one time, the company was offering the batteries for sale, but now they’re available only through a service agreement in which SolarCity maintains ownership of the panels and battery and the homeowner signs a long-term deal to buy the electricity.
The battery option requires a $1,500 down payment and an extra $15 per month, Carlson said, but so far customers seem to be responding positively.
“It’s going well,” he said. “Customers are happy to have the reliability, and it’s relatively seamless when the grid goes down.”
The biggest challenge to date — a challenge which Carlson said is “approaching resolution” — has been that California utilities weren’t prepared for the interconnection of battery systems and had been making the process “prohibitively expensive.” Recently, however, the state’s Public Utilities Commission issued a ruling that strips away some of the red tape and is more favorable to solar installers.
SolarCity has offered the solar-plus-battery system as an option from time to time, but it’s apparently not available in all parts of the state at all times, which may help explain why there are only about 300 customers so far. The company has made “some limited offerings to customers for certain periods of time,” Carlson said.
Commercial customers use batteries differently
On the commercial side, it’s a completely different story. Commercial systems are designed to lower power bills for customers by reducing peak power demand, which significantly affects rates. Batteries store power generated by solar panels during the day, and “intelligently dispatch” the electricity when demand is the highest, company spokeswoman Holly Canales said. Among customers of SolarCity’s Demand Logic program are eBay, Walmart, and HP (Hewlett-Packard).
Here’s how it might work: a big box store gets a surge of customers after work, let’s say at 6:00 p.m., just as output from its solar panels is starting to drop. The batteries could kick in at that point to avoid a spike in the consumption of grid electricity, ultimately reducing the store’s electricity rate for that month.
Integrating a battery in a residential system in such a way that the power could offset grid consumption on a regular basis would theoretically help customers save money, too (as long as the customer has time-of-use billing). Stored power could be used to heat water or run a clothes washer at night, when off-peak rates are lower. But the difference between peak and off-peak rates isn’t significant enough now, Carlson said, to justify the high cost of batteries.
“Right now,” he said, “there are not market mechanisms in place for that residential homeowner to be compensated for helping the grid with a battery in that way,” he said.
“The primary reason is that the specific benefit for the commercial customer is that we’re addressing their demand charges, which is their peak power consumption over the course of a month,” Carlson continued. “Residential customers aren’t charged for their peak demand. They’re only charged for the energy the consume over the course of a month.”
But, he added, battery storage for solar systems is the future. “Our long-term goal is that we see energy storage as a very critical enabler to very widespread deployment of solar,” Carlson said. “At some point, we’re simply going to need energy storage that will absorb surplus solar during the day and provide that energy at night and provide the balancing across the entire connected grid. Our goal is to offer batteries to enable that.”
Grid-tied lead-acid systems are ‘few and far between’
SolarCity looks ahead and sees more grid-tied battery systems. But for now, the residential experiments in California and Australia are a rare exception.
Fortunat Mueller, co-founder of the Portland, Maine, renewable energy company ReVision Energy, says relatively few of the solar electricity systems the company installs include battery components. When they do, batteries are conventional lead-acid batteries. He estimated that less than a half-dozen of the 200 or 300 systems ReVision installs annually include batteries.
A big reason is the high cost. Lead-acid batteries are roughly half the cost of lithium-ion automotive batteries, he said, and even then can add between $15,000 and $20,000 to the cost of a PV system. Moreover, batteries must be replaced periodically. A reliable backup generator that runs on fossil fuel can be had for $5,000 to $10,000, so the economics aren’t really there for a wholesale switch to batteries.
“Lithium-ion batteries are very expensive compared to lead-acid for the same amount of energy storage,” he said, “and unlike a vehicle application, power density is not so important in this application.”
The great benefit of lithium-ion batteries is their relative low weight relative to the amount of energy they can store, he added. “It matters a lot in a car or a bus,” he said. “It matters not so much in your basement.”
Most of ReVision’s solar installations are grid-tied, and Mueller sees this as a plus, at least in climate zones where winters are long and cold, and solar potential can be lacking at times of the year. “One of the beautiful things about grid-tied systems, net-metered systems, is the seasonal energy storage that is built into that,” Mueller said. “In other words, you can use the sunshine you capture in June to meet your loads in December. That’s the beauty of grid-tied, especially in our climate where there’s a significant variance in performance from season to season.”
Off-grid installations create real challenges for homeowners in cold-weather regions. If you size the system (the PV array and the batteries) for the worst two weeks of the year, the system is way oversized the rest of the time. Or you make the system smaller and run a generator during periods of low solar potential.
“So the less difference there is between the worst week of the year and the best week of the year the better,” Mueller said. “You’re better off in Colorado than you are in Maine, and you’re better off in Hawaii than you are in Colorado.”
Jun 5, 2014 9:28 PM ET
Jun 19, 2014 2:04 PM ET