guest-blogsheader image
0 Helpful?

Canadian First Nation Gets Active About Passive Housing

The British Columbia First Nation community finds conventional housing just doesn't do the trick

Posted on Feb 2 2017 by Katie Hyslop

Editor's note: Yale First Nation is a community in British Columbia, Canada, of some 160 members. This post originally appeared at The Tyee.

Like many First Nations in Canada, the Yale First Nation has struggled to provide its members housing that withstands southwestern B.C.’s nine months of rain without breaking the bank.

Yale receives a maximum of $169,000 from the federal government to build a house. That’s enough for a single-family, wood-frame house or, as Yale First Nation Chief Ken Hansen calls them, “B.C. box houses.”

The houses meet the basic B.C. building code. But that’s not saying much. Such “stick-built” on-site houses can take six months to a year to put up, so long as the Yale area’s frequent rain delays co-operate. And even when complete, the to-basic-code structures are drafty. Lingering moisture leads to mould and rot.

Nonetheless, Yale has built 14 “B.C. box houses” of three or four bedrooms each for rent to members in three different reserve communities. Those tenants pay for the structures’ poor quality on an ongoing basis, said Crystal Sedore, housing manager for the Yale First Nation: “In the winter, we have a couple of houses that are over $200 a month to heat.”

For many tenants, that’s a lot of extra money to come up with. Often it falls to the band to bail them out by paying the bill. “It’s just one more thing that the band should not really be doing, but we have an obligation to make sure that our membership has heat and hydro,” Sedore said. “So we do it.”

So when the band decided to invest in building some new rental housing, they knew what didn’t work. What were needed were homes that would cut down on energy costs, withstand the wet climate, and be suited to singles and smaller families.

That led Yale to Langley, B.C., in the Vancouver suburbs, and to Britco, a modular building company. Yale contracted Britco to build 10 two-bedroom units in a pair of buildings that meet the high-efficiency Passive House design requirements.

A six-plex in Ruby Creek reserve just south of Hope, B.C. is expected to welcome its first tenants at the end of January. Construction on a smaller four-plex is slated to begin this spring in either the Stullawheets or Dogwood reserve north of Hope.

“For us, the appeal was not only are we being environmentally conscious, which is very important to our chief and council,” Sedore said, “but also to build housing that is beyond minimal acceptable standards. We want something better, and our membership deserves better.”

Turn on the lights to stay warm

Passive House is a home designed to be so energy-efficient that it can stay warm at 17°C (62.6°F) with residents’ body heat, energy from the sun, and turning on the lights.

Like net-zero energyProducing as much energy on an annual basis as one consumes on site, usually with renewable energy sources such as photovoltaics or small-scale wind turbines. housing, Passive Housing relies on strict construction standards and material specifications to ensure as little heat seepage as possible.

That means more insulation than standard building codes require, triple-glazed insulated windows that face the sun to take advantage of nature’s heating system, and a heat-recovery ventilation(HRV). Balanced ventilation system in which most of the heat from outgoing exhaust air is transferred to incoming fresh air via an air-to-air heat exchanger; a similar device, an energy-recovery ventilator, also transfers water vapor. HRVs recover 50% to 80% of the heat in exhausted air. In hot climates, the function is reversed so that the cooler inside air reduces the temperature of the incoming hot air. system to ensure fresh air cycles through the house while maintaining internal temperatures.

Homes meeting Passive House standards require up to 80% less energy, and reduce greenhouse gas emissions by the same amount, compared to conventionally built houses. That’s significant not only to tenants’ pocket books, but also in helping meet Canada’s national emission targets. Twelve percent of our greenhouse gas emissions come from buildings.

A rendering of one of two Passive House projects planned at Yale First Nation in British Columbia, Canada. The units will rent for less than $600 per month. (Image courtesy Britco)

Britco boasts that their previous Passive House project, in Bella Bella, B.C., takes as much energy to heat on the coldest day of the year as turning on six 100-watt incandescent light bulbs.

For the Yale First Nation, that same performance means significant savings.

“We’re looking at hydro bills estimated to be $10 to $20 a month for heating and electricity” in these new units, Sedore said. Yale will track the two complex’s energy use and share the data, providing a valuable test case for modular Passive House designs in other communities, regardless of whether or not they’re Indigenous.

“I’m hoping to lead by example,” said Chief Hansen.

Fewer construction risks

Best known for its bright orange trailers used as offices or first aid centers on construction sites, Britco expanded into affordable housing seven years ago. After the 2010 Winter Olympics, it re-assembled modular units it had originally supplied for the Games’ staff accommodation into a total of 156 affordable housing units in six buildings in Chilliwack, Surrey, Enderby, Chetwynd, Saanich and Sechelt.

The company’s first Passive House development was the one in Bella Bella: six town homes built for Vancouver Coastal Health staff. From conception to finish, the whole project took seven months in 2015 — highlighting one way that modular housing differs from conventional on-site “stick built” construction. Building the same structure the old-fashioned way, subject to the weather, might easily have taken up to a year.

Modular housing is built off-site under more controlled conditions. Britco does the majority of its construction inside an Agassiz warehouse where it takes 30 days to complete one unit of Passive Housing, with multiple units under construction at the same time.

“It’s probably a half to a third the time of stick-built [construction],” Sedore said. In fact, Yale’s units could have been delivered in as little as three months, she says, if Yale First Nation had been the sole sign-off on funds. As it was, waiting for funding approvals from Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. (CMHC) extended the whole process from signing the contract with Britco to moving in new tenants, to six months.

Hansen said the nation met with and considered other modular home providers in B.C. and Ontario, but it was Britco’s relationship with indigenous communities that tipped the scale in its favor.

Company President Obie Erickson is well known in the Yale community, which sits on traditional Yale First Nation territory. “They engage First Nations and they do it in a proper manner,” Hansen said.

The company partners with First Nations on projects, employment and skills training, and has donated modular buildings to remote Indigenous communities for use as libraries.

Keeping it affordable

While CMHC funding differs by location, the Yale First Nation’s maximum of $169,000 per housing unit, while enough to build family-sized homes to the province’s basic building code, doesn’t generally cover the additional costs of Passive House construction — estimated to be 10% to 15% more than conventional units with similar interior finishings.

The Yale First Nation negotiated to bring costs down by replacing carpet with linoleum and not including furniture. In the end, the projects came in exactly within the federal government’s budget, Sedore said.

All 10 units in the two buildings will be two-bedrooms. The one-story units in the four-plex will rent at $375. Rents for the market-rate townhouses in the six-plex have yet to be set, but Sedore estimates they will be between $525 to $600 a month.

Many will be occupied by single tenants currently living in family housing that’s too big for them, Sedore said. While not every tenant is pleased with that exchange, she adds, it will allow some of the 16 families currently on Yale’s rental housing wait-list to move back to their community. (Yale is also renovating existing rental units, including making them more energy efficient.)

Feedback from membership and the band’s ad hoc housing committee on the project’s design has been “amazing” so far, Sedore said. Most of the excitement has to do with the buildings’ look and feel, not their Passive House aspect, Sedore admits. But she attributes that to a lack of appreciation so far for the difference between energy-efficient and conventional design.

“I think once we get tenants in and they start to see those real savings,” she said, “they’ll be really happy to see this brought onto reserve.”

And if modular Passive homes can deliver on their promise of cheaper, faster, healthier housing in Yale, other communities in Canada might be happy to see some of those savings, too.


Tags: , ,

Image Credits:

  1. Katie Hyslop

1.
Feb 2, 2017 10:54 AM ET

Edited Feb 2, 2017 11:20 AM ET.

literally passive houses
by Erich Riesenberg

I have never seen passive house described this way.

"Passive House is a home designed to be so energy-efficient that it can stay warm at 17°C (62.6°F) with residents’ body heat, energy from the sun, and turning on the lights."

Though I suppose with the right / wrong light bulbs...


2.
Feb 2, 2017 11:30 AM ET

Erich
by Malcolm Taylor

That kind of rhetoric worries me, as does the expectation that the total monthly electrical bill will be $10 to $20. In the same climate, paying the same rate, my very modest non-heating electrical bill is around $80.

Providing good, appropriate housing for First Nations is a serious challenge not only because of low construction budgets, but also the lack infrastructure, ongoing maintenance, and social problems, which often lead to over-crowding and subsequent moisture damage.

What's needed is a clear-eyed assessment of what any housing type can and can't do. Building up unrealistic expectations isn't useful. Resilience and robustness are what will determine how successful these houses are. Managing indoor humidity is the key, and hopefully the mechanical ventilation systems will help with this, although relying on them makes the units more vulnerable if they fail. Good luck to to them. I hope they do turn out to be as nice as they anticipate.


3.
Feb 3, 2017 8:44 AM ET

Response to Ercih Riesenberg
by Martin Holladay

Erich,
I agree that the sentence you quote -- "Passive House is a home designed to be so energy-efficient that it can stay warm at 17°C (62.6°F) with residents’ body heat, energy from the sun, and turning on the lights" -- is confusing. I'm not sure what author Katie Hyslop means by this sentence.

If "17°C (62.6°F)" refers to the outdoor temperature, the sentence doesn't mean much -- because almost any building can stay warm when the outdoor temperature is that mild.

If "17°C (62.6°F)" refers to the indoor temperature, the reader immediately wonders, "What are the outdoor conditions?"

Scott Gibson (GBA's news editor) has contacted Katie Hyslop to ask her to explain her intended meaning. We'll post her answer here when we receive it.


4.
Feb 3, 2017 9:58 AM ET

Edited Feb 3, 2017 10:06 AM ET.

mild climate
by Erich Riesenberg

I interpreted it to mean the interior temperature stays around 62°F.

Also: "Britco boasts that their previous Passive House project, in Bella Bella, B.C., takes as much energy to heat on the coldest day of the year as turning on six 100-watt incandescent light bulbs."

Bella Bella BC has a relatively comfortable climate, and in my experience 14 kwh per day (600 watts * 24 hours) could heat a highly insulated home in that climate.

https://weatherspark.com/averages/27565/Bella-Bella-British-Columbia-Canada

However, details such as house size, insulation amounts, and heat type are not mentioned.


5.
Feb 3, 2017 10:22 AM ET

Temperature clarification
by Scott Gibson

In response to our email, Katie Hyslop wrote: "I mean an interior temperature on a cold day. So in winter you don't need to turn on the heat: If you've got lights on and warm bodies in the house it should stay 17°C inside [62.6°F]."


6.
Feb 3, 2017 10:26 AM ET

Defining Passive House
by Martin Holladay

Thanks, Katie, for clarifying your meaning. Under some conditions, the interior air in a Passive House will be 62 degrees F, even without any space heating.

That said, (a) this is not the definition of a Passive House, and (b) the indoor air temperature in a Passive House that is being operated without any space heat will vary, and may range lower or higher than 62 degrees, depending on (1) the outdoor temperature, (2) the amount of sun, (3) the number of electrical appliances in use, and (4) the number of occupants.


Register for a free account and join the conversation


Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!