Helpful? 0

Insulating the roof deck with both closed-cell and open-cell foam?

I am consulting on a home where the HO wants to have the insulation at the roof deck. They are thinking 2” of closed cell followed by 6” of open cell.

The HO put forward this idea.

2" closed cell at the roof first to provide the vapor barrier then followed by 6" of open cell which will be enough to encapsulate the top chord of the roof truss and minimize thermal conduction.

Does anyone have any experience with this type system?

Is there any concern of the two layers of foam de-bonding from one another?

Asked by Mark Parlee
Posted Sat, 03/29/2014 - 14:12
Edited Sun, 03/30/2014 - 06:07


3 Answers

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Helpful? 1

Climate matters. I know that you live in Iowa, so I'm going to assume that we are talking about climate zone 5 or 6.

First of all, I know that it's possible to spray open-cell foam on a layer of cured closed-cell spray foam. Joe Lstiburek sometimes recommends that approach. When I interviewed him for an article on insulating low-slope roofs, Lstiburek said, “We fix the problem roofs ... one of two ways. ... The usual way we repair them is from the inside. We take out the gypsum ceiling and the insulation, and we spray 2 or 3 inches of closed-cell spray foam on the inside of the roof sheathing and the inside of the short walls. ... Then we repair the ceiling and we blow the space full of cellulose. If the space is too deep to fill with cellulose, we sometimes blow low-density spray foam over the high-density spray foam, because low-density foam is cheaper than high-density.”

The only tricky part of the solution you are suggesting is making sure that the ratio of low-permeance insulation (the closed-cell foam) to high-permeance insulation (the open-cell foam) is correct. In theory, if there is too much open-cell foam (or too little closed-cell foam), then the inner surface of the closed-cell foam might be cold enough in the winter to permit condensation. One consolation, however: if any condensation occurs, it will be on the cured closed-cell foam rather than vulnerable roof sheathing.

For more information on doing the calculations to reassure you about the ratio between your closed-cell and open-cell foam, see these two articles:

Calculating the Minimum Thickness of Rigid Foam Sheathing

Are Dew-Point Calculations Really Necessary?

Answered by Martin Holladay, GBA Advisor
Posted Sun, 03/30/2014 - 05:50
Edited Sun, 03/30/2014 - 05:52.

Helpful? 1

Mark, can you get a foam manufacturer to state in writing that their open cell product will stick to another company's closed cell product, or does one manufacturer make both products and agree that they work together?

I'm sure it would cost more, but you could go with 6"+ of closed cell and get better R value overall and covering the trusses, eliminate any dewpoint issues, and eliminate any bonding issues. Of course you need to make sure they don't spray too much at once and cause problems that way.

Seems like a manufacturer could provide a solution for you on this one.

Answered by David Meiland
Posted Sun, 03/30/2014 - 12:00
Edited Sun, 03/30/2014 - 12:10.

Helpful? 0

The foam is from the same manufacturer and the letter is a good point.
I am early to this one and the insulation is a side issue as part of the consulting. I went to review the framers work or lack thereof.
The report is in preliminary stages and is 17 pages long at this point but I am sure will balloon to 30 plus pages; of course most of this is captioned pictures.
Martin, Thanks for the link, Will let you guys know what happens as we proceed.
If you think of anything else please do not hesitate.

Answered by Mark Parlee
Posted Sun, 03/30/2014 - 13:50

Other Questions in GBA Pro help

In General questions | Asked by Dawn Roberts | Aug 30, 14
In Green products and materials | Asked by John Alberti | Aug 26, 14
In Energy efficiency and durability | Asked by Jason Haché | Aug 29, 14
In Green building techniques | Asked by scott schroeder | Aug 29, 14
Register for a free account and join the conversation

Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!