Q&A: A Forum for Green Building Experts and Beginners

[Click map to enlarge]

Please register for a free account or sign in to ask and answer green building questions.

The usual rules of courtesy apply:
1. Be nice.
2. If you can't be nice, be polite.
3. If you can't be nice or polite — well, please be brief.

To attach a photo or illustration:
Under the box labeled "More explanation," look for the words "File attachments."
Click that, and you should be able to attach a photo.

Thanks for joining the conversation!

1 Answer

How to air seal from interior with pine siding?

We just gutted the interior of our ~1950 cape on Long Island (NY). The Bottom layer of siding appears to be Pine 1x in good shape with cedar shingles on top of that. I want to air seal the siding from the interior, what's the best way to do this? I assume caulk, but which type? or could I caulk strips of tyvek into the bays?

Question #2:

Asked By christian routh | May 29 15
1 Answer

Is it advisable to use nail base insulation panels over a roof insulated with closed cell spray foam?

We are renovating an old railroad station, turning it into a residence and are gearing up to put new roofing on the building. Built in 1888, the building has massive overhangs on all sides and the rafters are mostly 2x6s with 4x6s spaced about 8' apart supported by large brackets. We had planned to use closed-cell spray foam insulation in order to get the maximum r-value in the relatively shallow rafter bays. Also, we want to maximize the available head room in the second floor rooms. The underside of the roof will also be the ceiling with t&g beadboard installed directly to the rafters.

Asked By Jodi Gunderson | May 29 15
4 Answers

Attic ceiling project

OK...read lots, know lots, but have a tough situation: 1924 unvented hot/cold attic, shallow rafters (4"), plank roof deck, asphalt shingles/tar paper and wishing to finish the attic space for office/play area. Previous owner installed very thin layer of foil faced batt against roof deck at least 15 years ago--no thermal impact, but more importantly there has been no moisture issues for the past 43 years (28 him, 15 me). I really don't want to go closed cell spray.

Asked By Chris Haddox | May 29 15
20 Answers

Is there a standard factor General Contractors use when calculating their fee to construct?

I am in discussion with a builder to construct my new home in zone 4B. We have engaged the services of an energy modeler to determine how to build the most efficient house within the budget. We are grossly over budget, at the moment. I noted that the GC has build a 16% fee into the budget to build the house. This is on top of all the subs and the contigency. Not wanting to negotiate something I have no background on, I'm wondering if this is a negotiated fee or is there some standard? I understand my builder needs to make a profit but I would love to get 16% return on my investments!

Asked By Scott Schroeder | May 22 15
6 Answers

Recommendation for unvented cathedral ceiling retrofit from outside

I have a 1980's cathedral ceiling section (2x12 raftered) of my home with soft sheathing problems. Hence, I need to remove the sheathing and re-roof. Most recommendation are to spray foam against the sheathing, but this requires an additional interior drywall removal and the interior mess and disturbance I'd prefer to avoid. There are also recommendations for large 6+ inch of rigid foam to the outside of the sheathing, this causes difficulty with the home appearance at the eave and problems with adjacent roof lines that aren't cathedral.

Asked By David koeberlein | May 28 15
2 Answers

Overinsulating or underinsulating?

We have a home built in 1986 in Columbus, Ohio (Zone 5). We are replacing our siding due to hail damage and plan to have the following layers on our home:

1. drywall
2. 2x4 walls with unfaced batt fiberglass insulation (R?)
3. polyiso 1/2"? - (old, some gaps, foil faced, says "R3.6" on the face)

4. 3/8" EPS w double foil face (~R1.5) - http://www.thermalbuildingconcepts.com/technical/propertySheet/ps-Physic...
5. Tyvek
6. Cedarmax insulated vinyl siding (R2.4) - http://www.proviaproducts.com/productdetail/vinyl-siding/cedarmax/

Asked By Chad B | May 27 15
10 Answers

Skylights that sit flush but don't leak! Do these exist?

I am trying to daylight a currently unused attic under a shingle roof. Because we're in a historic district, we're not allowed to visibly alter the roof's silhouette (so no dormers or protruding skylights). My architect has proposed switching to a standing seam metal roof with thin glass skylights slotting into the metal seams (as seen in the attached pic). I'm worried that the lack of flashing will lead to leaks. Does anyone have experience with skylights that sit flush but don't leak? Or am I chasing a unicorn?

Your feedback much appreciated!

Asked By Nathalie Jordi | May 27 15
3 Answers

Confused — We are in the process of remodeling a home in upper N.H.

We have used Zip R on the exterior sheeting, Zip board on the roof sheeting and foamed the interior to R-27 wall and R-38 roof. We were ready to install radiant floor heat using warm board.

I am thinking mini split for the 2nd floor bedroom and return hot water for the main floor and basement.

Asked By Joseph Maraldo | May 28 15
1 Answer

Basement slab perimeter insulation

I was told that the updated code for Zone 5 required R-10 Foam for 2' around the perimeter of my basement. Local code has not updated to the modern one that states this, but I would like to do this anyway. My question is...does this mean 2' of foam going vertical against the footing, or 2' of foam horizontal butted up against the footing that goes around the inside perimeter of the basement? I am trying to understand what the benefit of just 2' does?


Asked By Nicholas C | May 28 15
17 Answers

Unvented roof underlayment and rafter bay insulation

Hi guys...first time poster, love the site its been a huge help. I've just finished framing my home in Montana and am ready to move on to the roof. It consists of multiple single pitch decks ranging from 1.5" - 2" in 12. Framing is 2x12 rafters.

Asked By Adeeb Hattar | May 27 15
Register for a free account and join the conversation

Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!