Q&A: A Forum for Green Building Experts and Beginners

Q & A Instructions

[Click map to enlarge]

The GBAGreenBuildingAdvisor.com web site has a wealth of articles on a wide variety of construction topics. Before posting your question, you may want to check out the articles on this page: How To Do Everything. You just might discover an article there that provides the information you seek.

Please register for a free account or sign in to ask and answer green building questions.

If you want to post a question, the usual rules of courtesy apply:
1. Be nice.
2. If you can't be nice, be polite.
3. If you can't be nice or polite — well, please be brief.

To attach a photo or illustration: Under the box labeled “More explanation,” look for the words “File attachments.” Click that, and you should be able to attach a photo.

Thanks for joining the conversation!

1 Answer

Rake flashing on a low slope roof.


I am reading up on guidelines for rake/gable flashing for snaplock and most say to install the trim directly over the snaplock, with butyl tape underneath where the screws go. See here: http://www.westform.com/products.php?s1=residential&s2=prolok_12_16

Is this really the best way to install rake trim? Having exposed screws on a snaplock roof seems to defeat the purpose. With that being said, has anyone ran into any issues with this application?

I have also seen rake trim installed over z flashing, where there is no exposed screws.

Interested to hear your guys thoughts.

Asked By Tommy87 | Oct 23 17
30 Answers

Automatic control for passive solar overheating in winter?

Hi, I’m designing a passive solar house and attempting to gaining the most energy from the sun, but the more energy you try capture, the more likely overheating becomes a risk on those warmer, sunnier winter days. I was thinking it would be simple enough to have an ERV with a bypass that can exchange overheated indoor air (say 80°F) with the cooler outdoor winter air (say it’s 60°F) when the indoor temperature hits a upper limit setpoint (say 75°F) and the outdoor temperature is cooler.

Asked By Mike AbiEzzi | Oct 20 17
0 Answers

Poly or MemBrain?

In Maine, zone 6, zip code 04240. Finishing a large bonus room over a garage.
2x6 wall construction: vinyl siding, house wrap, osb, roxul; all in place.
Finishing the inside wall is the next step. T&G boards will be used, but have not yet decided if drywall will be installed first.

Need to decide on correct air barrier and/or vapor barrier. 6mil poly is the usual method, but with summertime AC in use, I am thinking this may not be the best choice. Will Certainteed MemBrain be a better choice for this application? Or should I just use the poly and not worry about it.

Asked By Tony Bouchard | Oct 22 17
4 Answers

Closed cell spray foam/cellulose combination

To all,

Background: 1500 Sq Ft. single level home, Northern Minnesota Zone 7, almost 10,000 HDD.

I am getting ready to insulate my double studded walls. The wall cavity including 2 2x4 24"OC studs separated by a 1" gap for a total cavity of 8". The ceiling has 2' energy heel trusses with 24+" of blown in cellulose

The original plan was to insulate the whole wall in cellulose, and at R3.9/inch the goal was 31 with no thermal bridging. Inside the cavity there was going to be a smart membrane (Intello Plus)

Asked By Steve Lenertz | Oct 21 17
5 Answers

Drainage and/or waterproofing for stem walls

Hi all.

I am planning to dig a trench around a garage (stem walls with interior slab on grade) to install some EPS foam.

The soils are clay heavy.

Would it be worth:

1) Also adding drain pipe next to the footing with crush stone, geo-fabric and sand back fill thereafter? NOTE: the garage is an attached and is slightly uphill of the house, which itself does not have exterior drains. So my thought is that, at the least, this may help divert some water from the house which has a basement.

2) Also waterproofing the concrete.

Asked By Tyler Keniston | Oct 22 17
4 Answers

Can you safely close air intakes?

We added solar panels to our house this year and switched our boiler from propane to electric. We have been optimizing our system of radiant heat through the floor by utilizing programmable thermostats and utilizing the variable speeds of the pumps pushing the water through the floor. We noticed today that we have cold air intakes almost directly above the thermostats in two rooms. It feels like the A/C is on while the heat is on. A hand-held laser thermometer is showing the cold air intake at 48 degrees directly above the thermostat which is set at 65 degrees.

Asked By GaryJanL | Oct 22 17
1 Answer

Hot Spot Energy: anyone heard of them or used their products?

Tripped over a company (small?) I'd never heard of with neat energy recovery products called hotspotenergy. Anyone ever worked with them or their products? I'm particularly interested in the ac waste heat recovery devices.

Asked By Keith H | Oct 22 17
4 Answers

Vaulted ceiling, open attic

I have two vaulted ceilings that I am trying to work out how to insulate. I have read all the material here on insulating cathedrals. However these are essentially a variant on an unconditioned, vented flat attic. If the roof is 6/12, the ceiling is 3/12. Unfortunately while they are not a classic cathedral with only a stud's depth, they still have very little space between the ceiling joist and rafter, ruling out fluffy insulation. (The R-38 batts already brush the roof sheathing halfway down the slope) Dense pack, of course, I hear is a very bad idea due to moisture.

Asked By pshyvers | Oct 21 17
3 Answers

How to get Passive House educated?

Hi everyone,

Asked By DHTaylor | Oct 21 17
9 Answers

Foam first or last in cold enclosed porch floor?


I have seen this question answered many ways while searching online, so I thought I would pose it here. I know there is another thread on this topic, but it seemed worth posting again.

When insulating an enclosed porch that is not climate controlled, should the layering be: pink foam board affixed to the floor underside, fiberglass batts, plywood for vermin control?

Here's the application:

Asked By JonesyHome | Oct 12 17
Register for a free account and join the conversation

Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!