What type of building envelope should I use on my resided house in Seattle?
We have a two story house in Seattle that was built in 1976. It has 2x4 exterior walls with R-11 rolled fiberglass insulation between the studs – has brown kraft paper vapor barrier on the inside of the house walls, has foil vapor barrier on the inside of the unheated garage; then on the studs is foil backed kraft paper, ¼” of white foam insulation board, then aluminum siding. It looks like they use slanted 1x4 bracing in the corners for shear bracing. There doesn’t appear to be any plywood on the exterior of the walls. Looking at current earthquake building standards in Seattle, we are nervous about the lack of shear wall support. So we had an engineer do an earthquake retrofit design that removes all siding down to the studs. We anchor the sills to the concrete walls, brace the walls with plywood, and connect the two floors together for the earthquake retrofit. Now we need a new house exterior. And since we are adding plywood and other items with depth to the studs, we thought it would be a great time to replace the half of the windows in the house that are single pane.
I thought this would be fairly easy, but with lots of considerations there are lots of questions about how to reside the house. We plan to leave the R-11 insulation in between the studs, and then nail the 1/2” plywood to the studs on the exterior for shear strength. We did not want to lose the current R value from the ¼” foam that is removed if possible. Looking at various Green Building Advisor topics I can get various pieces of information, but can’t complete a final wall profile.
Seattle is in climate zone 4C marine, moderate temperatures year round, 30 to 80 mostly, but can get down to 10 and up to 90 occasionally, but moderate humidity much of the year. British Columbia to the north has required a 10 mm or 3/8” wide rain screen gap since 2006, and Oregon to the south has required a 3 mm or 1/8” rain screen gap since 2010. Seattle is at least as wet as they are, so it seems like we should be including a rain screen in our residing plan. Reading many articles, including Joseph W. Lsitburek’s articles, “The Perfect Wall”, and “Mind the Gap, Eh!”, gives me insight, but not total clarity for my total house reside. I have read Martin Holladay’s numerous articles, including “Calculating the Minimum thickness of Rigid Foam Insulation.” As far as we know, our current siding has not had water issues for 38 years, we would like this residing to last that long in our damp climate with no or low maintenance, and to not break the bank.
So calculating the minimum thickness of rigid foam insulation for Seattle is ≥ R 2.5. Using that with the Perfect Wall - the Residential Wall, it seems like I could construct my new wall, inside to out as –
1. Keep this existing -
a. gypsum board interior walls,
b. 2x4 studs,
c. R-11 rolled fiberglass insulation that has brown kraft paper, between the studs;
2. then add new -
a. ½” plywood for structural sheathing attached to studs,
b. Hardie Wrap weather barrier – the items above would dry inward, the items below would dry to the outside
c. ½” thick R 2.5 XPS solid foam board,
d. 6 mm (1/4”) thick homeslicker rainscreen – provides gap for drainage
e. Hardie Plank lap fiber cement siding
1. Have I interpreted the readings of the above mentioned articles correctly so my house will be able to breathe and dry and not mold? If not, what changes are needed?
2. Will nailing the hardie plank through the ¼” thick rain screen and though the ½” thick XPS hold the hardie plank securely to the studs? So the Hardie plank won’t sag over time?
3. Will the above nailing compress the homeslicker rainscreen so much that it will not be effective? Would using ¼” thick lathe instead of ¼” thick rainscreen provide a longer lasting and cheaper separation barrier gap?
4. Lstiburek says a 3/8” gap for a rainscreen is conservative and it is required in British Columbia. Oregon only calls for 1/8”. Is ¼” enough, or since we are going to all of this trouble, we might as well go for a 10 mm or ¼” gap? We want a reasonable long lasting good, dry house that won’t have to cost a whole lot.
5. In Seattle, 15 pound felt and just a water resistive barrier like tyvek is all that is required to meet code I believe. So most contractors are not familiar with installing rainscreens. But it seems like with our damp climate a rainscreen system makes sense. I hate to hire someone to learn how to do this system on my newly resided house. The basics seem to be fairly straight forward, but the details around the windows and drainage seem to be where we could get into trouble.
6. Other suggestions on materials that might work as well as or better than above? I really don’t have a big preference in any particular product; the above just seemed like options that might work.
Posted Fri, 05/02/2014 - 14:36
Other Questions in Green building techniques
Minisplit setup for New Jersey, 750 sq. ft. house over crawl. Bouncing my HVAC contractor's plan off you guys.