Q&A: A Forum for Green Building Experts and Beginners

Q & A Instructions

[Click map to enlarge]

The GBAGreenBuildingAdvisor.com web site has a wealth of articles on a wide variety of construction topics. Before posting your question, you may want to check out the articles on this page: How To Do Everything. You just might discover an article there that provides the information you seek.

Please register for a free account or sign in to ask and answer green building questions.

If you want to post a question, the usual rules of courtesy apply:
1. Be nice.
2. If you can't be nice, be polite.
3. If you can't be nice or polite — well, please be brief.

To attach a photo or illustration: Under the box labeled “More explanation,” look for the words “File attachments.” Click that, and you should be able to attach a photo.

Thanks for joining the conversation!

1 Answer

Structural Wall

My husband and I are looking to take out a small "lip" of a wall and aren't sure if we can do so. Let me post a picture:

Also, I don't think we can take out what I labelled as "possibly this" because I think it's a beam, but I'm not sure. If we can, I'd like to.

As for what's in the basement underneath, here is a picture that faces the same way:

Asked By Sarah Poulin | Feb 2 16
2 Answers

Insulating old Victorian

Good day,

First, thank you for providing this service as it is appreciated. Second, I saw a recent post on insulating old Victorians and it applies to me also.

Background: 1888, double, 5000sq ft Victorian in Columbus, Ohio. All 40 windows are bad and replacing this Spring. Insulation is non existent or questionable.

One of many issues: Insulation: On one side the past owner built a 6-8 inch interior sheetrock wall around the outer walls. There are some unfinished rooms which I can see dirt insulation in between, but still unsure of the entire area.

Asked By Loren S | Jan 30 16
5 Answers

I'm adding 1 1/2 formular foam to outside of 2x4 wall. Is there a ledger strip to protect the edge of the foam and also allow for 3/4 rainscreen ventilation?

It would be nice to have a product that would protect the edge of foam and then transition to insect screen for the rainscreen 3/4 inch. And then it would be great if it was available with a a vinyl siding start strip built in also! I may be asking for a lot, I know but is there such a product? Thanks, Dave Green

Asked By Dave Green | Feb 1 16
11 Answers

Larsen truss with veranda (roof and deck)

So I'm considering the Larsen truss for my addition. 2x4 load bearing walls on 16" centers, 1/2" plywood on top for shear, poly on that for vapour barrier, followed by about 8-12" of Larsen truss cantilevered out from the foundation (2x2/2x3 inside with plywood spacer to 2x2/2x3 on the outside), then 1/2" plywood and wooden siding. Roxul batt inside (for easy utilities) with blown in cellulose on the outside.

Asked By Terry Sharpe | Jan 12 16
1 Answer

What is the ideal choice of cladding over OSB-Sheathed SIPs?

Hey Martin,

I find myself in a situation similar to one discussed here in the past regarding putting masonry, i.e. thin veneer, over SIPs. The original question was regarding which WRB to use. However for me, unlike the pervious poster, I have time to make course corrections. You previously said this was a "particular risky combination." I would like to know your recommendation of cladding over SIPs if stone veneer is not a good choice.

I live in Maryland, so we get plenty of rain. Just FYI.

William Lohr

Asked By William Lohr | Feb 1 16
6 Answers

Should I fix these attic vent baffles?

My builder recently added the attic vent baffles to my house under construction. I looked at them and realized that when I had read about attic vent baffles on Green Building Advisor, these don't follow the recommendations and I'm looking for opinions on how much impact this will have and if I should have them make a modification.

Right now there is no ceiling drywall or insulation up there, so it would be "easy" to make a change, but in a week we hope to have ceiling drywall and insulation blown, so then it would become too late.

Asked By Nick Hall | Jan 26 16
7 Answers

Innie or outie windows with exterior foam?

CZ 7 Northern MN, 2x6 standard frame with 4" exterior foam. Exterior foam is basically unknown here. My builder and the local lumber yard person think I should go with innies, because they both feel the windows would get too cold being on the outside of the wall. My windows will be Marvin double hung, fiberglass or aluminum out, wood in. I had thought I would go with outside windows because I thought it would be easier (cheaper) to extend the frame inside, than extend the trim outside, but I am not stuck on either one. Thoughts and comments appreciated.

Asked By Steve Vigoren | Jan 31 16
2 Answers

they didnt completely hook the cold air return on my furnace is that ok what could happen

can just using indoor instead of fresh outside air cause any problems

Asked By Roger Blankenship II | Feb 1 16
5 Answers

Fixing Basement Insulation

We recently purchased a newer home in zone 5.5. The unfinished basement is insulated with fiberglass batts framed between 2x4 spaced 24" apart. It has poly vapor barrier against the concrete, then it looks like R-19 unfaced batts, then another layer of poly vapor. The studs are spaced about 1" away from the poured concrete walls. I was thinking of removing the vapor barriers and batts and insulating between the studs with 3" XPS foam. The question is how best to do that?

Asked By Mel Tillyard | Jan 31 16
0 Answers

Slab Floor Construction

I was a watching a video today of a slab on grade construction at a new build PH in Ireland. Their buildup was radon barrier, concrete, and then what appeared to be 2 layers of 4" thick polyiso-like sheets. The sheets were to be taped into aerated concrete blocks around the perimeter to maintain the thermal envelope. Seems as if in the US, the insulation layer is usually underneath the concrete. I know in a retro you can put foam on top of concrete, but anyone know why is it not typically done this way in new PH builds here, especially if you don't want a finished concrete basement floor?

Asked By Jonathan Lawrence | Feb 1 16
Register for a free account and join the conversation

Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!