Q&A: A Forum for Green Building Experts and Beginners

Q & A Instructions

[Click map to enlarge]

The GBAGreenBuildingAdvisor.com web site has a wealth of articles on a wide variety of construction topics. Before posting your question, you may want to check out the articles on this page: How To Do Everything. You just might discover an article there that provides the information you seek.

Please register for a free account or sign in to ask and answer green building questions.

If you want to post a question, the usual rules of courtesy apply:
1. Be nice.
2. If you can't be nice, be polite.
3. If you can't be nice or polite — well, please be brief.

To attach a photo or illustration: Under the box labeled “More explanation,” look for the words “File attachments.” Click that, and you should be able to attach a photo.

Thanks for joining the conversation!

5 Answers

BIBS fiberglass dense pack vs. cellulose dense pack

After reading about all I could find on dense pack fiberglass vs cellulose (which is much less then I'd have expected)...I decided I'd love to have cellulose in our new +- 3000sf home/shop that is being built in Western SD...BUT...I cannot find any professionals to install it.

We have taped the seams of the osb and brought the air seal across the ceiling. We are installing a HRV. Lets call it zone 6b

Asked By daryl stisser | Feb 18 15
17 Answers

Cold living room floor

So, like many people, I have a cold living room floor above my garage. I have begun to pinpoint several areas of major air leakage to address (thanks to renting a thermal camera from Home Depot). One major issue that I discovered (and already suspected) was that the garage ceiling has very poor insulation. I have a second story bay window cantilevered above the garage door (garage townhome). This past summer I had to have the bottom paneling replaced due to wood rot.

Asked By Neil Lambrecht | Feb 16 15
3 Answers

Can closed-cell spray foam be applied to the underside of the decking of a flat roof that has rigid insulation & EPDM above it?

I am from Winnipeg, Manitoba (Climate Zone 7a).
I'm planning to build a cottage with a low-slope roof (0.5:12).
I was planning the layers like this (top to bottom):

  • EPDM (fully bonded)
  • 1.5" HD Isoboard
  • 5.5" rigid XPS insulation
  • 3/4" T&G plywood decking
  • 12" I-joists with 3" closed-cell spray foam applied to underside of plywood
  • drywall

I'm assuming that that the close-cell spray foam will be acceptable as a vapour retarder.

Asked By Jake Harms | Feb 19 15
3 Answers

I am considering using double stud walls in building a net zero house in Charleston, SC

I cant find any information on the best Exterior Wall system for a Hot & Humid Climate, does anyone have experience building in that environment?

Asked By Rick Fetter | Feb 18 15
10 Answers

Longterm durability of Youker system 1.5" thin slabs

John Seigenthaler describes thin slab concrete systems that can be used as thin pour slabs over subfloors. There is a specific mix (which I intend to follow) along with some control cracks.

Gypsum is not preferred due to thermal conductivity and cost.

Does anyone he any long term experience in the longevity of these pours? I was more concerned with making sure my subfloor was designed with little deflection of L/480 or L/600 to minimize the root cause of the cracking, floor the subfloor not supporting the floor evenly.

Asked By Michael McArdle | Feb 13 15
2 Answers


Does anyone have any rough ideas what kind of cost premium PERSIST and REMOTE are over standard upper end construction? By upper end I'm thinking well sealed/insulated standard 2x6, 3.0 ACH50, $300/sq ft overall, etc. Just trying to get an idea if we're talking 5% extra or 20%.


Asked By Walker Angell | Feb 19 15
8 Answers

What combination of foam insulation for this wall?

I've got a wall that has seen substantial water damage, and the existing fiberglass insulation is destroyed (along with the studs, sheathing, and sill, but that part I've got covered).

The existing wall was:
1/2" sheetrock, paper-faced fiberglass between 2x4 16oc, 1/2" ply sheathing, 1/4" EPS, aluminum siding

I despise fiberglass insulation. The contractor who is doing the repairs asked me what I would like instead of fiberglass, but I'm not sure what to spec.

I'm in central NJ.

I would prefer 3.5" foil faced polyiso.

Asked By David Pfeffer | Feb 18 15
1 Answer

To French drain & sump crawlspace next to full basement or not?

In my Frankenstein of the house I have three basements. Original one from 30s (concrete foundations and floor - full height) in the center of the long house. Also on one side I have 70s basement, that I want to finish at some point, since it has more than enough head room.

Both 30s and 70s basements have a sump. 70s basement has perimeter footer French drain that drains into sump pit with two pumps. 30s basement does not have footer drain, just the sump with lots of holes in the liner.

Asked By Apollo S | Feb 18 15
10 Answers

Vapour barrier is installed...should I remove it?

My insulators have finished and installed a 6 mil vapour barrier....they blew in fibreglass insulation in the 2 by 6 cavity .I have 2 layers of EPS totalling 5 inches on the outside walls and have staggered the seams. The building inspector has passed the insulation .My builder is unsure of the need for an interior vapour barrier . The inspector said it's there now so leave it. My advice from this forum is to get rid of it or slash it to make ineffective . The house is being built in zone 6 climate in Canada .

Asked By bob holodinsky | Feb 17 15
7 Answers

Converting Vented Attic to Nonvented Attic

I've been researching several methods to insulate my attic. First, some background.

I live in Maryland and own a house that has the HVAC system in the attic. Currently the attic is vented and has zero insulation anywhere. Not ideal!

From my research, it looks like the best option is to make the attic a conditioned (nonvented) space. I'm unsure of what to do, and I'm unsure of the most economical way to do it. The attic is fairly small at about 1,000 sqf total.

Option 1:

Asked By Samuel Burton | Feb 10 15
Register for a free account and join the conversation

Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!