GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter X Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Picture icon Hamburger Icon Close Icon Sorted

Community and Q&A

Are the following practical and effective heating system retrofits? ECM motor, Outdoor Reset, Thermal Purge

wlarsen | Posted in Mechanicals on

Hi folks,

Are the following products practical and cost-effective heating system retrofits (i.e. installed on existing systems)?

ECM Motor (for furnaces)
Outdoor Reset Control (for boilers)
Thermal Purge Control (for boilers)

Does anyone actually install them as retrofits? Or are heating systems more like cell phones nowadays, where you just get a new one instead of upgrading/fixing?

Thanks for the help,
Whitney

GBA Prime

Join the leading community of building science experts

Become a GBA Prime member and get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

Replies

  1. Expert Member
    Dana Dorsett | | #1

    Retrofit heat purge controllers/economizers for boilers are cheap & effective. The Intellicon 3250HW+ is cheap & effective heat purging economizer suitable for cast iron boilers, and has a good track record. There are other more sophisticated models out there with other functions, but it's not clear they work any better (or even as well.) It's DIY-able for those with some electrical skills. The greater the degree of boiler oversizing for the heat load the greater the fuel use reduction, but low double digit percentage savings are common.

    Retrofit outdoor reset controls for cast iron boilers is a mixed bag from an efficiency point of view, and will often short-cycle a boiler into lower efficiency, or worse- potentially destroying the boiler with return water that's too cool if not implemented correctly. It needs careful system analysis & setup, but they exist, and sometimes provide efficiency improvement.

    I'm not aware of retrofit ECM drive blowers for hot air furnaces, and would be surprised if they existed. There are many ways it could be problematic, unless the retrofit was designed and specified for particular models through the original manufacturerer.

    ECM drive circulation pumps for hydronic systems exist, and can cut the electrical power use in those systems dramatically. Some are programmable for setting the delta-T on a loop or progammable fixed flow rates, or programmed temperatures, etc. There's a variety out there- the Taco Bumblebee and Viridian series are pretty popular with hydronic designers, as are the Grundfos Alpha series. In the right hands with the right analysis the full system efficiency can often be improved, not just the power use portion. But even in the hands of DIYers a lot can be done with these smart pumps. (You still have to be able to read a pump curve, and understand the characteristics pumps you are replacing though.)

  2. wlarsen | | #2

    Thanks!

  3. jj1 | | #3

    Hi Whitney: actually replacement ECM furnace blower motors are available from two manufacturers: the Concept 3 (aka Fieldpiece LER motor) and the Evergreen IM model. Martin Holladay wrote a typically excellent summary at: https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/community/forum/mechanicals/20709/swapping-ecm-psc-fan-motor
    NREL has published a comprehensive summary and cost/benefit analysis of the Concept 3 at:
    http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy14osti/60760.pdf
    NREL concluded that the typical $20 p.a. electricity savings provided an inadequate payback relative to the approx. $475 installed cost, unless of course the existing blower motor needed to be replaced anyway, or unless the homeowner used the furnace fan ON mode during all/most of the year.

  4. user-2890856 | | #4

    Dana , as usual hit many relevant points . Thermal purge is a very good technology , especially if you purge the leftover heat in the boiler to your water heater or a tank prior to your water heater . Nothing sucks up excess heat better than a big tank of water .
    There are many things that can be done with water based systems that are altogether less expensive than ripping out everything and replacing with something cheap . Whatever anyone does with these systems to renew them though , you must take a system approach , not just replace parts .

  5. Expert Member
    Dana Dorsett | | #5

    BTW: The Concept 3 / Fieldpiece LER retrofit air handler ECM motor is apparently no longer available.

    The Genteq Evergreen IM series are around, and can replace some split capacitor air handler motors at about $300 / pop (f.o.b. the distributor's warehouse, not the installed price.)

Log in or create an account to post an answer.

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |