GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Audio Play Icon Headphones Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Picture icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon
Building Science

An Epidemic of Duct Disease and Enclosure Problems

A report of the day I spent going on air conditioner service calls with an HVAC pro

A 12-inch disconnected supply duct greeted us in the first home we visited, and this wasn't even what got the customer to call.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
View Gallery 8 images
A 12-inch disconnected supply duct greeted us in the first home we visited, and this wasn't even what got the customer to call.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
Photo #2: A dirty filter in the air conditioner choked off air flow and froze up the evaporator coil.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
Photo #3: A blown capacitor stopped the air conditioner from running. It's an easy fix.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
Photo #4: A tangle of flex duct connected at a ductboard junction box. Notice the flex duct being squashed by the junction box.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
Photo #5: An air conditioner in attic has enough troubles already. Why make it worse with such a bad duct system?
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
Photo #6: Long flex ducts that end with sharp turns take a lot of extra blower energy to move enough air.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
Photo #7: Dormers, vaulted ceilings, and attic kneewalls - Common building enclosure problems that can make the upstairs of your home too hot. This house had 5 dormers, and the spaces between them brought a lot of heat into this home.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard
Photo #8: The vaulted ceiling here had fiberglass batt insulation, poorly installed. The attic kneewalls had no insulation. This laundry room had more heat gain than the air conditioner could handle with the one small vent installed there.
Image Credit: Energy Vanguard

When an air conditioner breaks down in hot weather, homeowners reach for their phone. The HVAC company then sends someone out to the home with the immediate goal of getting the AC running again so the occupants will cool off. The thing is, though, that most homes have problems that run deeper than the cause of the broken air conditioner.

Last week, I spent a day going on calls with Phil Mutz of Moncrief Heating & Air Conditioning. It was a good reminder for me of what it’s like to spend all day responding to homeowners’ air conditioning complaints. I’ve written before about the summers I spent going on calls with my grandfather, who owned an HVAC, electrical, and plumbing company in Leesville, Louisiana.

Phil and I went out on five calls last Thursday, four of them for homeowners with problems keeping their homes cool. We got the air conditioners running again without much difficulty, but we also saw a lot of other problems begging for attention. Here’s a brief rundown on what we found.

Call #1: No cooling upstairs

This was a fairly new house, probably less than 5 years old. The system had power, so we went straight to the attic and found the dirty filter you see in Photo #2 (below). The AC hadn’t been cooling at all, so Phil figured that the evaporator coil had frozen up. We replaced the filter and turned it back on. The ice had melted after they turned the system off, so when we turned it back on, it worked.

Well, when I say it worked, I mean that it started blowing cool air again. We know that because we had direct access to the cool air while we were in the attic: A 12-inch supply duct was completely disconnected from the supply plenum, as you can see in the photo above.

That’s a lot of cool air being lost to the attic. I wonder how long it was like that. When Phil asked about cooling in all of the upstairs rooms, the customer told him that her sister’s room was pretty hot even before the AC went out.

A third problem showed itself when we measured the static pressure. In this system, designed for 0.5 inch total external static pressure, we found 0.9 inch. That means reduced air flow. In this case, as in many, the system is probably oversized for the house and the blower is oversized for the coil, so the reduced air flow is probably about the right amount, sort of. It’s certainly not efficient, though.

Looking around the attic, I saw a fourth problem: a Swiss cheese building enclosure. It had vaulted ceilings, attic kneewalls, and lots of air leakage sites. It had insulation that missed being in contact with the air barrier. And the cable guy screwed things up again, too.

Lessons: (1) Homeowners can keep their AC running by changing the filter. (2) Homeowners can spot disconnected ducts by poking their head in the attic or crawl space. (3) Too many duct systems have air flow problems. (4) You can cool a tent with an air conditioner, but you’ll spend extra money doing so.

Call #2: No cooling anywhere

A three-story townhouse, probably less than 10 years old. One zoned system served the first and second floors. Another system served the third floor.

Problem #1: Dirty filter (photo #2 below). We were 2 for 2 here. Again, the coil probably had frozen up but melted before we arrived. We checked the refrigerant charge at the condenser, as well as the superheat temperature. After replacing the filter and cleaning the condenser coil, the system worked fine.

The third-floor system wouldn’t come on at all. Phil figured that the capacitor was blown, and indeed it was. When he opened the condenser panel to take a look, the condenser cap was blown outward (photo #3 below), the telltale sign that it had “popped.”

This house also had a pretty bad duct system, but the homeowner couldn’t afford to do anything about it. That would be quite expensive, too, since the first and second floors are served by ducts that are mostly buried behind drywall. Thinking of buying a townhouse? You may well end up with a similar piece of crap.

Lessons: (1) Homeowners should replace the filter regularly. (Have I mentioned that yet?) (2) Capacitors last about 5 to 7 years, according to Phil, so you’re gonna lose your AC sometimes. Even worse, it’s most likely to happen in hotter weather because the AC runs a lot and the capacitor doesn’t have a chance to cool down. (3) Have a knowledgeable pro take a look at the HVAC system if you’re thinking of buying a townhouse.

Call #3: No cooling anywhere

This was one of those cases that’s both really easy and really hard. Their system wasn’t coming on at all. It’s a zoned system. We went into the attic and asked the homeowner to turn it on. And…

Voilà! We fixed it. Well, not really. The system came on and started cooling again. Phil figured there’s an intermittent problem with the zone control board. Maybe it just needed a reset and will work fine now. A more likely possibility is that Moncrief will be back out there trying to track down exactly what’s happening.

Intermittent problems can be very difficult to find and fix. “I don’t like to replace parts unless I catch a problem while it’s happening,” Phil told me.

Oh, and again, the duct system was a mess. Lots of flex. Ductboard junction boxes (photo #4 below) squishing flex ducts. The standard fare.

Lessons: (1) As with computers, rebooting solves some problems. (2) It’s hard to find a house with a good duct system.

Call #4: Water damage on ceiling

This one was different, and the water damage had to do with a bad condensate line. But let’s cut to the chase and go straight to the duct system. The air conditioner we looked at was in the unconditioned attic. We were there in mid-afternoon, so it was HOT up there. I don’t generally sweat a lot but I was sweating that day. Anyway, you can see what we saw in photo #5 below.

How many problems do you see there? Here’s my short list:

Problem #2 means that the duct coming off the top will get more than its fair share of the air. That big turn of ~120° will choke it down a bit, but still, you shouldn’t put a supply duct right at the end of a plenum or trunkline. (Mike MacFarland of Energy Docs in California does this on some of his jobs, but he says it only works when “your supply takeoffs are well designed/thought out, and when you provide supply dampers for all outlets at the plenum for airflow balancing.”)

Photo #6 below is another example of how poorly the installers of this system understood air flow. Sharp bends add a lot of resistance!

Lesson: No matter what the cooling problem is, it seems that most homes visited by an HVAC repair person are full of bad duct systems.

Call #5: Cooling problem upstairs

The homeowners here are in the process of moving into this 50-year-old home in Atlanta and have noticed that it’s difficult to cool the upstairs. The closets get very hot and the laundry room gets even hotter. Yes, they have a typically bad duct system, but the bigger issue in this home is heat gain.

If you’re a home energy pro, you know what the problems are already just from photo #7 below. This house had 5 dormers on the front, and you can see two of them in the photo above. The attic spaces get very hot. The walls aren’t insulated well — or at all. The vaulted ceiling insulation isn’t doing its job either. Heat pours into the conditioned space.

We couldn’t get into the spaces between the dormers to see how well they were insulated, but the laundry room (photo #8 below) on the back side of the house had a scuttle hole. Before even looking into that attic, though, I knew that those innocent-looking surfaces you see in the photo were guilty of First Degree Heat Gain. I could feel it in the air of the room. I could feel it by how hot the walls and ceilings were. Looking and seeing no insulation on many of the surfaces only confirmed what I already knew.

Lesson: Even with a functional air conditioner, some building enclosure problems are so bad that they really need to be addressed. This is one of those cases.

At the end of the day…

I really hate that expression, but in this case, I did indeed get to the end of the day of my ride-around with Phil of Moncrief Heating & Air. And, at the end of the day, I saw a bit of what HVAC service pros see every day. I imagine many of them suffer from PTSD.

When an air conditioner service company gets a “no-cool” call, their immediate concern is to get the AC performing up to its capacity again. Many customers only want that cool air blowing out of the vents again and don’t want to go further. Of course, many of those no-cools are easily preventible by regular maintenance, like changing the filter.

Some customers, however, have the resources to fix the bigger problems, and are interested in doing so, and that’s why HVAC companies are well suited for home performance work. Once you know about building science, you understand that “the box” is only one component of the heating and cooling system, which also includes the duct system, the building enclosure, and internal heat gains. Then it becomes difficult to go in and just change out a filter or capacitor without also addressing the other problems.

Moncrief has been around since 1898, so they’re used to focusing on the box, like most HVAC companies. In the past decade, though, they’ve begun the transition to putting HVAC in the context of home performance. They’re addressing the duct system problems and regularly measure static pressure, for example, and have been involved with some spray foam jobs to fix faulty building enclosures.

If you’re in the HVAC business and not doing these things, just look at all the business you’re missing out on and all the customers you’re not helping as fully as you could. If you’re a homeowner, keep in mind that your problems with cooling may have other causes. Also, change your filter. Go, do it now. I changed mine today, and I’m embarrassed to admit that it was past due (although not as bad as the two above).

Allison Bailes of Decatur, Georgia, is a speaker, writer, energy consultant, RESNET-certified trainer, and the author of the Energy Vanguard Blog. You can follow him on Twitter at @EnergyVanguard.

3 Comments

  1. But Why? | | #1

    (4) You can cool a tent with an air conditioner,
    My neighbor actually has an off the shelf tent that he cut a hole in and installed an air conditioner. On most tent campsite that have electric, they don't charge you for usage so why not be comfortable while camping? Pocket and some duct combined with a window air unti and you too can be the envey of the campground.

  2. J S | | #2

    Dormers
    Dormers are fine if they are insulated properly, right? Or do they always cause heating issues?

  3. User avater GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #3

    Response to J.S.
    J.S.,
    Dormers are hard, but not impossible, to insulate.

    In most cases, dormers project from insulated sloped roof assemblies. Because the dormer interrupts normal vent channels, the best type of roof assembly (if you want a dormer) is an unvented assembly. For this type of assembly to work, you need to pay close attention to air sealing, and you need to be sure that your R-values are high enough. For more information, see How to Build an Insulated Cathedral Ceiling.

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Related

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |