GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Audio Play Icon Headphones Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Picture icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon
Energy Solutions

Plastic Film Kits, Insulated Shades, and Interior Storm Windows

Choosing window attachments that (actually) keep heat in

Image 1 of 3
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory used infrared (IR) imaging as part of its field testing for ongoing research on the energy performance of window attachments. These three photos show the same window, with an interior low-e panel attached, under three different pressure conditions simulating windy weather. Even with a fairly tightly sealed interior window panel, the moderate wind level significantly increases air leakage.
Image Credit: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory used infrared (IR) imaging as part of its field testing for ongoing research on the energy performance of window attachments. These three photos show the same window, with an interior low-e panel attached, under three different pressure conditions simulating windy weather. Even with a fairly tightly sealed interior window panel, the moderate wind level significantly increases air leakage.
Image Credit: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Low-e storm windows can bring the performance of single-pane windows up to par with low-e double-pane models. As an exterior device, these attachments may not be accepted in some historic areas or condominium communities. Low-e interior panels are a good option in these situations.
Image Credit: Peter Yost
Window attachment research by the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory has included computer modeling, lab testing (shown here), and field testing. In this photo, technicians from the independent Air-Ins lab in Montreal are testing the airtightness of a fixed window unit. Once the unit is completely sealed, they will install interior window attachments at various distances from the window frame in order to test for convective heat-flow patterns in a guarded hot box thermal chamber.
Image Credit: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Try this little perceptual experiment now: look at yourself in a mirror (or your computer or phone camera). Then look at your left eye, and then your right eye, and then back and forth several times. What do you see?

If someone else is around, ask them to look at you, and look back and forth between your eyes.

What do you see? When you’re looking at someone else moving their eyes back and forth, that’s exactly what you see. But when you look at yourself in the mirror, you never see your eyes move. When I do this, I can see that my eyes are at a slightly different angle, and I can feel a tiny break in the string of perception when moving them, but I can never see my eyes move.

Why not? The best explanation that I have heard (and please email me if you have a better one) is that while we think of our experience as an uninterrupted “movie,” that movie is actually composed of many tiny “clips,” and our brains very often fill in missing details between clips. In this case, our brains are unable to see our own eyes moving while they are moving, so the short gap in perception is smoothed over as we watch the “movie.”

It’s time to check windows for winter-readiness

With the weather this hot, it’s hard to imagine that we would ever want to try to keep it in the building. (If you’re still more focused on keeping heat out of your windows, check out last week’s post.) But check your memory from January or so, and you may realize that we can’t skip over a whole season, and that now is the time to get ready for this winter by checking your windows and seeing if any modifications can help them keep you warmer when the time comes.

Winter window attachments use one of two methods to keep heat in: adding insulation to the window assembly, or improving airtightness.

Boosting window R-value is not that hard with kits

If you’re stuck with single-pane or other poorly insulated windows, there is hope: you can boost their R-value and slow down air leakage by covering up the whole window assembly with another layer of plastic or glass. The best products perform almost as well as high-end replacement windows and tend to have a lower price tag.

A box of clear plastic and double-sided tape is the least expensive and most widely available window attachment — and the performance isn’t too shabby. These kits, commonly found at hardware stores, provide modest insulation (adding an R-value of about 1), significantly reduce air leakage, and improve comfort by adding a layer between cold glass and warm rooms. They also help prevent condensation, and both renters and homeowners can install them cost-effectively.

Insulated shades add up to R-4, but watch your seals

If you don’t like to look at the film kits, or if you don’t like loosing paint when you take them down, you might prefer the benefits of conventional fabric window coverings and interior shades, which increase comfort by adding a warmer layer between the cold window glass and the heated room.

Conventional insulated shades improve R-value by 1–2, but higher-performing shades with side tracks improve R-value by up to 4! These products include cellular shades and “window quilts” that fit snugly to the window trim with side tracks or other fasteners. The shades need to be completely closed in order to provide the full thermal benefit.

If you have insulated shades and double-glazed windows, be careful in the summer. If insulated shades are deployed on a hot, sunny day on south- and west-facing windows, preliminary research indicates that overheating may occur: some modeled temperatures have gone above 200° F (93° C), which could damage seals and shorten the expected window life. Finding other ways to control glare and solar gain on south-facing low-e windows, such as awnings or conventional curtains, is probably a good idea until more is known.

Interior window panels offer several benefits

Fixed interior window panels (widely called “interior storm windows” even though they do not protect windows from the weather) offer unobtrusive high performance starting at a relatively low price and are especially popular in places where exterior storm windows won’t work — in historic homes, condominiums, long-term rental properties, and on dangerously high windows.

They are made of plastic or glass — sometimes even low-e glass, which costs more — and come with different framing materials (most commonly aluminum). Some have operable parts and can remain in place year-round, but most have to be removed seasonally; this is the main drawback of interior panels, as they can block emergency exits through the window and also require space for safe storage.

Low-e interior window panels offer a number of benefits when properly installed. They improve R-value by about 2, increase comfort by creating a barrier between the cold window glass and the room, and do a pretty good job of sealing air leaks; the tight seal on the interior also helps reduce condensation by preventing warm, moist indoor air from entering the window assembly and being chilled by the air near the cold glass. Low-e versions have a radiant barrier that further reduces heat loss, bringing the entire window assembly almost up to par with low-e double-pane replacement windows.

Costs will vary hugely

As with window attachments for keeping heat out, costs of window attachments vary hugely. Film kits are cheap, while other options go up in price — but are often less expensive than replacing a window that’s not working for you. Check WindowAttachments.org for some great fact sheets on individual options and comparative costs. My colleague Peter Yost also offers a really insightful case study on getting the most of the windows in his house.

With my other colleague Paula Melton, Peter authored Making Windows Work Better, the recent feature article from Environmental Building News, to which I owe a lot of today’s advice.

Do you have windows that aren’t quite working for you, but you aren’t quite sure how to handle them? Other questions or comments? Post them below.

Tristan Roberts is Editorial Director at BuildingGreen, Inc., in Brattleboro, Vermont, which publishes information on green building solutions.

Also in this series:

Windows, Shades, Blinds, and Awnings

Replace That Window

3 Comments

  1. Li Ling Young | | #1

    Good for new construction too!
    With the cost of high performance windows arguably not commensurate with the value delivered in energy savings, interior storm windows (for condensation control) combined with insulating shades (for privacy) can bolster the insulating power of even pretty-good windows. I believe well-made, durable windows in the U .35 range coupled with interior storms and insulating shades will perform better than any comparably priced window. Until R-15 windows are commonplace, we should be pursuing alternatives that are affordable and higher performance.

  2. Darren Finch | | #2

    A north facing double paned entryway window question
    Hi there
    I have a 5 yr old colonial just north of Manhattan NY and have a 36sq ft Anderson 400 series window (guess without pulling out the huge ladder and checking the etch in the glass) over the entryway and while its double paned still feel drafts, so I was reading your article and was wondering if I had a interior panel made up (low e maybe)m I can resolve some of these drafts and maybe cut my gas bill as well (it would be permanent as its 20ft off the ground)
    So any ideas and maybe suppliers who could make it would be great
    Thanks
    Darren
    See photo attached

  3. User avater GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #3

    Response to Darren Finch
    Darren,
    If your problem is really air leakage, then the solution is to track down the air leaks on the inside of the window and to seal them with high-quality caulk.

    However, your problem might have nothing to do with air leakage. The cold drafts you feel might actually be due to interior convection loops rather than air infiltration. (If the glass is cold, interior air near the glass cools and drops to the floor, setting up a convection loop.) The cold feeling from this convection current is made worse by the radiational cooling that occurs when your warm skin loses heat to the cold glass.

    The solution to these problems is to add a storm window or to replace the existing window with a triple-glazed low-e window. You can call up a local storm window dealer for advice; your window is very large, which may complicate installing a storm window.

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Related

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |