GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Picture icon Hamburger Icon Close Icon Sorted

Community and Q&A

Attic insulation question

Bill Winch | Posted in General Questions on

I’m doing a gut renovation of a 1000 sq ft finished attic in NJ.

I plan to spray 5″ of closed cell foam between 6″ rafters and 3″ of foam on the attic exterior walls and put 3′ x 3′ doors on the side attics for access

Question: In addition to the insulation above, my Architect suggests insulating the knee walls of the side attics because he says the side attics are not heated space, but I don’t think this is a good idea because: 1) the insulation would be redundant 2) it might confuse the installers to where the thermal boundary is: at the kneewalls or at the rafters 3) there might be condensation on the cold surfaces of the unheated side attic .

What makes sense here? should I insulate the knee walls? Also, would you sheet rock the ceiling and behind the knee walls, inside the side attics (used for storage)?

Any input is appreciated. Thanks.

GBA Prime

Join the leading community of building science experts

Become a GBA Prime member and get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

Replies

  1. Mark Leder | | #1

    According to both LEED and NAHB Green, attic facing kneewalls must be insulated. You can do it a couple of ways. 1) Use open cell foam / cellulose / fiberglass but then you must install drywall or foamboard on the attic side. Tape/mud or foam all seams so there is no air leakage. 2) The easiest way is to use closed-cell foam, which acts as both a thermal and air barrier.

  2. GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #2

    Bill,
    You are in Climate Zone 4. According to the 2012 IECC, the minimum ceiling R-value in your climate zone is R-49. That means that you need a minimum of 7.5 inches of closed-cell spray foam between your rafters -- not the 5 inches you are planning.

    I don't think that you need to insulate your kneewalls; instead, you need to find a way to get an adequate amount of insulation at your roof plane.

    Mark: If LEED and NAHB Green require that kneewalls must be insulated, I am astonished. For at least 20 years, energy experts have been teaching builders that it makes more sense to insulate the sloped roof over (and behind) a kneewall than it does to insulate the kneewall.

  3. Expert Member
    Dana Dorsett | | #3

    Mind you, the HFC245fa blowing agents used in 5" of ccSPF has a lifecycle greenhouse gas (GHG) potential several times that of the energy use it's offsetting. SFAIK there's only one water-blown closed cell foam on the US market that doesn't have this GHG problem, but it's only ~R5/inch compared to ~R6/inch. (Brand name: Icynene MD-R-200, not to be confused with the MD-C-200 which is another HFC245fa-blown 2lb foam.) If you care about that issue, either limit the closed cell foam to 2" (which is more than enough for the air-seal and moisture control), and fatten out the R values with something else. With the water blown 2lb foam you'd want at least 3" (R15) for moisture control, since it's permeance is about a third that of most HFC blown 2lb foam. In most other respects (including mechanical rigidity and adhesion) it's comparable to the HFC blown goods. (And no, I don't work for the manufacturer.)

    What Martin said about insulating kneewalls. Air-sealing kneewalls is a fools-errand (and I've played that fool on multiple occasions). Insulating & air sealing at the roof deck is much more likely to succeed.

Log in or create an account to post an answer.

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |