GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Picture icon Hamburger Icon Close Icon Sorted

Community and Q&A

Insulating an Elevator Shaft

jcofvienna | Posted in General Questions on

I have a project in coastal Delaware, zone 4A.  The property is in a flood zone.  The house is designed with an elevator attached to the side of the main structure—think of a silo attached to the side of a barn.  The elevator shaft cross-section is approximately 6ft x 6ft and the walls are framed with 2×6’s on a short CMU stem wall.  The bottom portion of the shaft is framed with pressure treated lumber as it is below the base flood elevation.  The elevator shaft interior is within the air and thermal control layers for the overall structure.  We need to make some final decisions on how the wall cavities and the roof will be insulated.

Let me also add that my general contractor is good, but the inclusion of a rain screen and some of the air sealing measures I’m having him do are already outside of his standard building practices.  I’m looking for something effective and reasonably straightforward for a competent crew.

I had originally thought that the flood prone portion of the shaft would get closed cell spray foam in the wall cavities.  However, my GC tells me that when that section of wall does flood I’ll have to remove the insulation in order to insure the walls dry out properly.  If that’s the case, I think I’m inclined to use mineral wool in those wall cavities.  Above the flood-prone areas, I assume we will use the dense pack blown fiberglass the rest of the structure will get in wall cavities.

A hip roof has been designed for the top of the shaft.  My general contractor plans to frame that conventionally.  My thought was to ask him to use 2×10 rafters and pad out the bottom of those rafters with some strips of the extra 2-inch foam insulation panels he already has on site.  That would give me an 11.5 inch depth to flash and batt with about six inches of closed cell foam and the balance with the mineral wool batts (similar to option 5 in Martin Holladay’s article 5 Catherdral Ceilings That Work).

Does this sound sensible? Would it be easier to use fiberglass batts instead in the roof due to the uneven surface of the cured foam?    Do I need to add any strapping to ensure the roof batts stay in place?  Better alternatives?

Comments/thoughts welcome.  Thanks in advance.

GBA Prime

Join the leading community of building science experts

Become a GBA Prime member and get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

Replies

  1. charlie_sullivan | | #1

    How high up are you expecting to be subjected to flooding? Is there equipment that lives in that lower part, and how will it survive the flooding? How do you access that space to remove insulation to enable drying? How is the rest of the house designed to survive the flooding?

    Sorry for so many questions.

    1. jcofvienna | | #2

      Charlie - My nominal lot grade is elevation 4. Base flood elevation is being changed to elevation 6. I'm assuming a near direct hit of a monster storm could flood us to elevation 9 (BFE + 3 ft).

      The elevator will open at grade level. I know they have to dig a pit at the bottom of the shaft, but I don't know how much equipment goes in the bottom. Our plan will have much of the hydraulic pumps and tanks remoted to another storage area where we can locate it significantly higher.

      I'm assuming I can stow the elevator cab on a higher level when I need to access the bottom of the shaft and then just open the exterior door to the shaft if we need to perform maintenance (or remove insulation after a flood).

      The first level of the house is elevated to elevation 8 (base flood elevation plus two feet of freeboard) with a CMU stem wall that has been backfilled and a slab poured over the top. We're assuming that could still flood but we only have entry space, some storage, laundry, and utilities at that level. The remainder of the house is elevated on piles 12 feet up.

  2. Expert Member
    BILL WICHERS | | #3

    I would run whatever you're planning on doing past your elevator contractor -- there are a lot of special elevator codes and a lot of them are life safety related, so a big deal at inspection time.

    If you keep everything on the OUTSIDE of the shaft, that's probably a better way to go in terms of any issues with the elevator and related codes.

    Bill

    1. JC72 | | #7

      My two cents from a layperson.

      Think of the elevator shaft as you would an exterior stairwell? This means an insulated door for every level which the elevator opens to and that "house side" wall inside the shaft should be insulated like the exterior walls for the rest of the building. The other 3-sides can be built to whatever code requires.

  3. naswai | | #4

    I disregarded that weight limits matter until one day, I got stuck, and I freaked the hell out. Loading an elevator beyond its capacity comes with dangers, but I wonder how many people respect that? A stupid family is living in our building, and they're like always taking the lift even though only 2 people are allowed inside. As a result, the door won't close properly, and we always have to contact the maintenance company to solve the issue. By the way, we're thinking of changing the maintenance company. Have you guys may be used Hin Chong Lift Maintenance Services? I've heard they're great, but I'd like to listen to what you guys think about them.

  4. plumb_bob | | #5

    You should consider a sump at the bottom of the shaft so any potential water can be removed.

    As mentioned above, elevators are tricky code animals with many detailing requirements regarding sound transmission, fire, etc. The elevator installer should be brought in early in the design.

    An elevator shaft is essentially a chimney once a fire starts. The shaft walls should be constructed as fire separations, as should the room housing the elevator machinery/controls. Your local code may require smoke venting of the shaft as well.

  5. charlie_sullivan | | #6

    In case anyone hasn't noticed, this is a year-old thread, revived by a spammer using it as an excuse to link to an elevator service company. It would be helpful if there were a button to click on to report spam without adding comments that further bump the thread up in the active list.

  6. plumb_bob | | #8

    Hmmm thanks I did not notice. Damn spammers!

Log in or create an account to post an answer.

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |