“Martin Holladay” : 2 specific question on pole shed

Figured Mr. Holladay wrote the great article on pole sheds and not sure how/if I could send message on here (hence the call out / other member’s help welcome of course). I’m a younger small organic farmer in zone 5 northern half/third of Illinois. 2 specific questions on pole shed: 1.) I have vinyl layer under girts (MBA insulation dad had installed) and want to insulate more. People tell me to keep the vinyl insulation and work over it. I see drawbacks to trapping moisture, multiple potential “vapor barriers”, having leaks (not good air barrier), wall not being able to vent outwards ((I’m heating mainly, it could vent inwards w/ retarder)), etc. Not much in your articles that I’ve found on this topic. Would you keep it if it were yours (top 6/7 of wall vinyl is decent, but vertical seams would need taped w/ foam in corners maybe; does tape stick to vinyl???) 2.) When you say you would put osb/ply on inside of girts for “air barrier” on pole shed does that also include house wrap on the outside of the osb/plywood against girts or is it either or (you prefer osb/plywood I see)?
Martin—-great articles for do it yourselfers to understand what they are dealing w/ and figure best case scenarios, much gratitude.
I tend to ramble, thanks,
Matthew Currier
GBA Detail Library
A collection of one thousand construction details organized by climate and house part


Replies