GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Picture icon Hamburger Icon Close Icon Sorted

Community and Q&A

Plywood tape…

Lucas Durand - 7A | Posted in Green Products and Materials on

I would like to “compare and contrast” some different tapes for use on the rough surface of exterior grade plywood – for air sealing purposes.
The tapes under my consideration at the moment are:
1. Grace Vycor Plus
2. Berry Plastics Barricade OptiFlash 732-20
3. Mastic tape
4. Siga Rissan

All four tapes claim “agressive” adhesion.
Adhesion is one thing, conforming to the slightly irregular surface of plywood is another.
I only have direct experience using mastic tape but I can imagine that any of the first three will probably adhere and conform well.

The “Rissan” is a mystery.
A Siga brochure indicates that it bonds to “wood”.
It also says that some difficult substrates require priming with “Dockskin”.
I wonder if plywood is a difficult substrate?
Anybody ever tried Siga Rissan on plywood?

GBA Prime

Join the leading community of building science experts

Become a GBA Prime member and get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

Replies

  1. Lucas Dupuis | | #1

    First, I would look at Venture 1585CW-P2. It bonds well to plywood, even in cold weather. It lacks the same properties as the mastic based tapes, but is much more economical. I see where you're going with the Vycor, Optiflash, etc... Any tape with a bit of "give", like an asphaltic (vycor) or buytle (Optiflash) base would seem to fill in the irregular surface of the plywood. But here are some questions to consider when looking at this type of situation. How airtight can you reasonably expect the building to be? Is the plywood the primary air barrier, and are you using a wall assembly that requires plywood? The reason I ask is that OSB, and the HUBER system both provide a smoother surface if permeability isn't an issue. Are you concerned about long term adhesion, or potential air leakage through the gaps between the tape and the plywood? This could be an interesting thread as it raises a number of questions regarding how far we need to go to airseal a building.

  2. Mike Eliason | | #2

    Lucas,
    the guy to ask re: SIGA is albert rooks/small planet workshop.

    i think for wood to wood, the sicrall might be the right tape, not the rissan. depends on application. dockskin might be a good suggestion - in europe, OSB tends to be much smoother (sanded, i think) and it's not here in the states, so a little prep work makes getting the tape airtight a little easier.

    also, what about 3M's 8067?

  3. Albert Rooks | | #3

    Hi Lucas,
    You said exterior plywood. I want to make sure that the right product is considered. Rissan 60 is for interior applications, not exterior. If this is at the exterior layer, Wigluv 60 is the recommended product. It will stick to and conform to Plywood just fine. For either Rissan or Wigluv, plywood is not an issue at all. None of the US "woods" need a primer. In the US manual (current addition) it refers to some "woods" needing the dockskin primer. This is only for the soft wood fiber boards that they have in Europe. We have nothing like this in the US.

    Full disclosure: I am the SIGA Importer, so I have a strong bias. I brought it over to support the people in my region who are building to the Passive House Requirements. That said, your question about how tight do we need to go... My answer is 0.6ACH for my crowd. How to do that while maintaing exterior permeability is why I got into SIGA. The Wigluv 60 at the exterior layer is still permeable, and more so, than the plywood that you'd put it on.

    You can see the specs, some US based descriptions, and/or send me a mail at http://www.smallplanetworkshop.com... or call if that's helpful...

    Best Regards,
    Albert Rooks

  4. John Klingel | | #4

    I'm going to use plywood as my air barrier, and don't see why one shouldn't first use the APA, or airtight plywood approach (to twist "ADA" a tad). I am not familiar w/ tapes on plywood, but I would think Tremco acoustical underneath the ply would outlast the tape. I'll do both methods. OSB always seems a bit "oily" to me, and I can't imagine tape sticking to it as well as to plywood, either. Another reason to avoid OSB?

  5. Bob Coleman | | #5

    seems like as long as you have a backing behind it, some type of caulk like sealant would work best with any expansion contraction, and it will stick

    if you were to use something like grace vycor, you could always run staples into it to help it stay where it should. also using one of the approved primers on the wood before hand woudn't hurt.
    the zip system basically has a pre-applied primer on it that works with the tape

    taking a clue from the liquid applied WRBs, they use a mesh tape over joints and a mastic like substance as a filler before applying the liquid wrb. i'm sure if there was a tape that would work, they approve that too but they don't

    the large membrane peel and stick WRB sheets would work if money is no object

  6. Lucas Durand - 7A | | #6

    Thanks for all the responses.

    Personally, I intend to build as "tight" as possible.
    <0.6ACH50 would be great, however I am not interested in attaining PH certification.
    I believe "ultra-tight" doesn't have to be complicated if enough thought is put into devising a simple air sealing strategy.

    In addition to avoiding complex geometry, simple to me also means affordable and not too time consuming.
    In my case, detailing the plywood sheathing for air-tightness seems like a good way to achieve these goals... but there is still some strategizing to be done.

    The flashing tapes seem to offer a lot in terms of the performance qualities I'm looking for but are possibly too expensive to use large quantities...
    Maybe a hybrid strategy of using drywall gaskets and tape would be more cost effective...

    John Klingel, maybe "APA" is a good way to approach this...

  7. Lucas Durand - 7A | | #7

    Albert, thanks for the information.
    The "Wigluv" tape...
    How would you describe it as compared to a mastic-like tape?
    Is it "gooey"?
    Is it flexible?
    How does it's cost compare to the Grace Vycor which I would buy for something like $30/75' roll.

    Edit to say: Yes, the application would be exterior grade plywood

  8. John Reimers | | #8

    Lucas, Here is a link to the price list. The site says you have to buy a full box.

    http://www.smallplanetworkshop.com/storage/SPW%20SIGA%20NEW%20PL%201.21.pdf

    John

  9. Jesse Thompson | | #9

    Lucas,

    I would add the 3M Flashing Tape to your list. It's thinner and more flexible than Vycor, but seems to stick even better to rough surfaces, especially in cold weather.

    http://www.shop3m.com/3m-all-weather-flashing-tape-8067-bcsvcx6cxs.html

  10. GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #10

    In case anyone reading this thread hasn't seen it, it's worth pointing out that a section of the following blog discusses tapes for plywood or OSB: Air-Sealing Tapes and Gaskets.

    (I just added Jesse's suggestion about the 3M tape. Thanks, Jesse.)

  11. Lucas Durand - 7A | | #11

    Jesse, thanks for the suggestion.
    And John, thanks for the price information.

    The back of my envelope is telling me that Siga is in the back seat in terms of cost...
    I'm a bit surprised.
    Is the higher cost due to the fact that it's imported?
    Like buying parts for a VW?

  12. Aaron Vander Meulen | | #12

    Any reason why you're not looking at either the Huber Zip system or Grace's enV system?

  13. Albert Rooks | | #13

    Response to Lucas:

    The Wigluv works equally as well on plywood and OSB. It's not like either the 3M or Grace products. It's quite different from anything seen here in the US prior. It's extremely flexible and sticks like you wouldn't believe. The longevity target is 50 years in application.

    What makes it so different is that it is a Vapor Diffusive exterior air sealing tape with a perm rating of 1.2, is UV resistant and can be left exposed for 12 months uncovered. It has no rubber and no solvents or VOC's. That means it will not "embrittle" or have adhesion failure as solvent based adhesives do.

    All of that may seem rather extreme for the US, but it's a product made for the central European market where air-tight construction is "old hat" and products like this have been perfected. The market over there has moved from basic rubber/solvent tapes that seal and keep the water out, to specialized tapes that attempt to match the permeability of the layer that they are applied to. In that market, wall sections are typically an increasing diffusion open gradient to the exterior. That means the exterior tape needs to balance two potential perm levels: 0.6 to.7 for when it's applied to sheet stock (plywood/OSB) or the higher perm ratings of the higher quality housewraps (Siga Majvest 68 US Perms). The 1.2 perms is an ok balance and has proven reliable in it's ability to manufacture.

    So... Yeah. All of that with no solvents or VOC's (it's water dispersed). It costs a little more as higher quality products often do. I know it seems a little extreme for some of us here. If you don't feel that you need that level of product... Save a few bucks. As always, cheaper products abound.

    Best of luck,
    Albert.

  14. Albert Rooks | | #14

    Response to John,

    Thanks for posting the price list. It is always nice to ship full boxes (they ship easier), but not realistic. I had updated the web site that less than box is possible, but not the download price list yet. Thanks for the catch.

    So... any quantity is ok.

    Also, as luck would have it, I just shipped 2 rolls (yes... only 2 rolls) of wigluv 60 to complete a Passive House Project in wisconsin. There are pictures and video of it applied to OSB...

    http://www.naturalhomemagazine.com/blogs/blog.aspx?blogid=3180&tag=newenhouse

    Great project.

    Best,

    Albert.

  15. Lucas Durand - 7A | | #15

    Albert thanks again for the information.
    I have always thought the Euros made "air tight" construction look like "old hat".
    I think the Euros are way ahead of us North Americans in a lot of ways...
    As you suggest, I think it shows in their more "evolved" building products.

  16. Lucas Durand - 7A | | #16

    Aaron, I have looked at the Zip system.
    I know less about the enV system...
    My general impressions are that they would not be a good fit for my project.

    I want to stick to more conventional building materials as much as possible.
    Gaining access to enough material for either system would be more difficult for me than just using plywood.
    1/2" exterior grade plywood has a good permeability rating for an air barrier material in my climate.
    I'm not sure I want yet another learning curve at this point...

  17. Aj Builder, Upstate NY Zone 6a | | #17

    Slightly on or off topic..... has Huber ever answered the question... as to Zip OSB in that....

    Is Zip OSB sheathing, standard crappy OSB or is it made as well as their Advantech sheathings or is it something in between?

  18. GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #18

    AJ,
    Yes, they have answered the question. According to Michael Pyle, a Huber manager, Zip System panels are more water-resistant than ordinary OSB or AdvanTech OSB because they contain a “medium-density, phenolic-impregnated, kraft paper overlay” — in other words, an outer layer of plastic-impregnated paper.

    More about Zip System sheathing can be found here: All About Water-Resistive Barriers.

  19. Aj Builder, Upstate NY Zone 6a | | #19

    Outer layer is of course in good shape.

    I should have stated that my concern is for moisture coming from the inside. Condensation.

    I am assuming Advantech uses glues or whatever internally that are much more water resistant than typical OSB.

    Does Zip sheathing also use better internal glues like Advantech or just rely on the outer layer for outer only water protection and no inner water protection?

    Thanks so far for commenting Martin

  20. Aaron Vander Meulen | | #20

    My understanding of Huber ZIP and AdvanTech...

    According to our sealant supplier, they haven't been able to find anything that effectively works for gluing down AdvanTech because of the wax that's impregnated on the outer layer. We've tried Franklin and PL polyurethane and neither sticks long term. That being said, when the ZIP system was introduced, they hosted a breakfast at our yard with the rep. My first question was what happens when a nail is over driven. He claimed that as long as it didn't go through more just the outer layer it would be fine, the inner make up is very similar to AdvanTech. That being said, personally I would probably tape over any over driven nails. If installing on a customers house, I wouldn't dare use anything other that their tape, unless I had something in writing from Huber saying the tape I wanted to use would work. The Grace enV system is a liquid applied WRB, can be sprayed or rolled. IIRC gaps bigger than 1/4" need fiberglass mesh tape. To me it seems like the most bullet proof system out there.

  21. Lucas Durand - 7A | | #21

    Jesse,
    The 3M tape...
    3M says it uses an acrylic adhesive.
    Do you know how flexible this tape remains after it is applied?

  22. Jesse Thompson | | #22

    I've got some in my house that is still exposed and it's still completely flexible a year later, but that's not much of a test.

    Blake Bilyeu in OR had a good slide at his PH presentation this year of his test (180MB file!): http://passivehouse.us/passiveHouse/2010_Passive_House_Conference_Presentations,_November_5_files/2010%20Conference-Rue%20Evans-Blake%20Bilyeu.pdf

  23. Lucas Durand - 7A | | #23

    Jesse, thanks for the reference.
    The 3M tape isn't at all like I imagined it.
    It looks like it might be just the thing though.
    Lots of other interesting things in that presentation too...
    I like the gable end attic access...

  24. Jesse Thompson | | #24

    Lucas, I agree, they did a great job with that house.

    I'd love to hear a bit more about how they upgraded their Therma-Tru entry doors with multi-point locks and thermally broken sill to get a high performance affordable door. That's a very good trick.

  25. Bob Coleman | | #25

    would have been better had they put that 3m sample tape on a seam, and on something not laying flat

    joing movement and somewhat gravity are the enemies

    and grace enV or similar would be nice but you need to be next to a lumber yard that will work with ya for a do-it-yourselfer as buying whole pallets of the various components isn't practical

Log in or create an account to post an answer.

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |