GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Audio Play Icon Headphones Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Picture icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon

Community and Q&A

Split, Mini-split, or Air-Source Heat Pump?

Julie Klump | Posted in Mechanicals on

I am leaning towards mini-splits for a 30 unit 3 story affordable apartment building in Chicago but have been told that the cost of electricity makes that a bad choice. I know air source heat pumps are also all electric but is that a better choice? Apartment sizes range from 300 to 500. For an identical building a few blocks away we installed a high efficency individual gas furnace with condensors on the roof. We have an opportunity to try (experiment) with this building with another system. If the upfront costs were the same what system should we install based on use of energy.

Thanks for any help.

GBA Prime

Join the leading community of building science experts

Become a GBA Prime member and get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

Replies

  1. User avatar GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #1

    Julie,
    1. It's impossible to compare fuel costs unless you tell us the local electricity cost and the local cost of natural gas.

    2. A ductless minisplit system is a type of air-source heat pump, so when you talk about air-source heat pumps, your question is confusing. Perhaps you are comparing a Japanese-made ductless air-source heat pump with an American-made ducted air-source heat pump. If that is what you are talking about, the former will generally be significantly more efficient than the latter.

  2. Bob Coleman | | #2

    a 'mini-split' is an air source heat pump; the typical model has no ducts
    keep in mind you may not have local hvac people familar with the japanese models; a broken down unit might involve a full replacement

    at this time, natural gas costs win out, even for the foreseable future, especially if you already have natural gas plumbed into the building and venting established, or will already be using it for water heat, which means you have paid the monthly service charge.
    and you'll have a hard time heating during jan-feb-mar on a heat pump without lots of backup electric resistance heat, unless you build to near passive haus standards.

    i'm pretty sure comed got rid of electric heat resistance rates for new customers, so you can't save like you could in the past; ameren downstate did. plus the costs of seperate metering begin to eat any savings anyhow on a small unit.

    the best bet is a shared system especially if utilities are included in rent, like a large boiler providing hot water and heat to all the units. renters can then supplement if they want, with small electric heaters or window a/c units.

  3. Julie Klump | | #3

    Martin
    Sorry about that. We pay $0.12/kWh and $0.91/therm and yes i am referring to the Japanese mini split system. I guess another question is if i have to use ducts with a mini split am i losing efficency?

  4. User avatar GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #4

    Julie,
    1 therm of natural gas = 100,000 BTU
    If your furnace or boiler operates at 92% efficiency, that much gas yields 92,000 BTU of heat.
    If your mini-split heat pumps have a year-round average COP of 2.0, you'll need 13.5 kWh of electricity to supply the same amount of heat (92,000 BTU). The electricity will cost you $1.62 -- more than the $0.91 you would pay for the same amount of natural gas.

    If you choose a ducted air-source heat pump, your efficiency will definitely be lower than if you choose a ductless system.

  5. Jardon Hu | | #5

    If you choose a ducted air-source heat pump, your efficiency will definitely be lower than if you choose a ductless system. Why?

  6. User avatar GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #6

    Jardon,
    The reason that the efficiency of a ducted system is lower than the efficiency of a ductless system is that it takes a considerable amount of electricity to propel air through ductwork.

    If the system is perfectly designed, with all ductwork located inside of the home's conditioned space, then the electrical draw of the blower motor helps heat the house during the winter. However, the same blower motor adds to the cooling load during the summer.

    Even during the winter, the blower motor heat has a COP of 1.0 -- significantly less than the COP of an air-source heat pump. That lowers the average COP of the system.

    Of course, many HVAC systems have sections of ductwork that aren't located inside the home's conditioned envelope. In a house like that, you see major a degradation of the system's efficiency.

Log in or create an account to post an answer.

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |