GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Audio Play Icon Headphones Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Picture icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon
Green Homes

Sustainable Spec House in Coastal Maine Grabs LEED’s Highest Rating

A WELL-ROUNDED DESIGN. It's hard to write a concise description of this eclectic home. Familiar forms integrate well with sleek modern accents; traditional details and materials are blended in playful, contemporary patterns; but most important — cutting-edge solar technologies complement effective passive solar design.
Image Credit: Bernard Meyers
View Gallery 7 images
50% WILD. Half of this site was deliberately left untouched by the construction process. Upon the home's completion, landscapers covered much of the excavated area with native plants from local nurseries. They seeded less than 25% of the total site with a hardy fescue to create a drought-resistant, low-maintenance lawn. The permeable gravel driveway doesn't contribute to stormwater issues the way that most other paving materials would.
Image Credit: Wright-Ryan Construction
A LITTLE BIT OF SHADE GOES A LONG WAY. With relatively wide temperature swings from summer to winter, Maine's climate demands seasonal strategies for maintaining indoor comfort. Deep roof overhangs and sunshades add only a small premium to the home's construction costs, but if well placed, they can add up to big savings when it comes to summer cooling loads - especially in a passive solar design. The operable casement windows on all sides of the house contribute further by allowing natural cross-ventilation.
Image Credit: Richard Renner
THIS CURVED PORCH ROOF and recessed doorway offer a place to get out of the weather as you enter the home. The newly-planted ferns should fill in in a few years and anchor the house to the natural site.
Image Credit: Richard Renner
DAKOTA BURL CABINET FACES consist of sunflower hulls and a low-VOC urethane resin, making them both healthful and renewable. Solid wood trim in the home is FSC certified.
Image Credit: Richard Renner
THE DINING ROOM IS AT THE CENTER of the open floor plan. Open spaces make the spacious home seem even roomier. The large windows balance the connection to the outdoors yet keep the interior cozy.
Image Credit: Richard Renner
ATTENTION TO DETAIL is evident in the strategies for letting heat in and keeping it in. The blower-door test result of 0.12 ACH @ 50 Pascals proved that Wright-Ryan built a tight house. Richard Renner thoughtfully integrated seasonal shading components and high-performance windows for effective passive heating and daylighting.
Image Credit: Toshi Woudenberg
THE NUMBERS ARE STILL OUT. With a HERS index of 42, the house should use less than half the energy of a similar house that barely meets code requirements. When a year's worth of energy data has been collected, we'll post the results here.

A home that bridges the gap between mainstream and extreme green

The LEED for Homes pilot program was just getting started when Wright-Ryan Construction decided to build a spec house as a sort of green-building immersion course for its staff. Wright-Ryan invited Richard Renner Architects, a design firm with over a decade of experience in sustainable design, to help create what would become just the third LEED Platinum home in the country. Richard saw the project as both an opportunity and a challenge. Being a spec house, the design had to appeal the general public, but highlighting the sustainable aspects of the home was equally important. This balancing act went off almost without a hitch.

Trusted building details

Because they understood the challenge of constructing a durable, energy-efficient home in coastal Maine, they deferred to well-respected sources for guidance, including the research and publications of Building Science Corporation. This inspired some smart construction details, including offset headers and band joists that made room for rigid insulation and furred out siding that will dry more readily than if it were attached directly to the sheathing. The team also used a 24-inch framing layout, eliminated headers in nonload-bearing walls, and aligned rafters with studs and joists to keep lumber needs as low as possible.

Material choices demand just as much attention

Wright-Ryan and Renner didn’t stop at energy- and resource-efficient design – they also considered the source and health effects of their materials. Almost all of the lumber and trim materials were FSC certified. The few exceptions included locally harvested and milled wood flooring and Dakota Burl cabinet faces made from agricultural by-products. An equal concern for health called for easy-to-clean ceramic-tile flooring (containing recycled glass), low-VOC finishes and caulks, and a mechanical ventilation system.

Alternative energy should play a big role

Although the supertight building envelope is the foundation of the energy-efficient design (with an impressive pre-completion blower door test result of .12 ACH @ 50 Pascals), solar electricity, heat, and hot water are integral features. The metal roof supports a 2-kW, grid-tied photovoltaic (PV) system in one corner and three evacuated-tube solar collectors (with 30 tubes each) in the other. Solar hot-water collectors set to work well in the cold New England winters can create too much hot water in warmer months. The solar domestic hot water system is designed so that it can direct excess heat into the radiant heating system, which could help the house coast through the shoulder seasons. As a last resort or when the heating system is not in use, a branch of tubing that runs under the garage slab will safely expel whatever heat the house can’t use.

The home takes advantage of passive solar heating as well. The three south-facing dormers have properly proportioned roof overhangs that allow only winter sun to directly strike the upper windows. The same scenario plays out on the first floor, but in this case there’s a clever bank of louvered awnings providing the seasonal shade that prevents overheating in summer.

Keeping the outside green

Wright-Ryan took a conservative approach to developing the previously undisturbed wooded site. The company cleared only enough land for construction access and to ensure good solar exposure for the roof-mounted PV array and solar hot-water system. After completing the house, landscapers planted ferns, indigenous shrubs, and wildflowers – all purchased locally – over more than half of the disturbed area. The crew thoroughly mulched all landscape beds to aid water retention and add organic matter. They seeded the small remaining lawn with a hardy, low-maintenance fescue. For permanent access, Wright-Ryan put in a simple gravel driveway – the least intrusive option.

Lessons Learned

Richard Renner feels that the finished home measures up well to the initial stylistic, functional, and performance goals, but he might tell you that the big lesson learned is “go with your gut.” The original plan was to build a fairly modest home, but a real estate consultant advised the team that both the site and the market warranted something larger. It probably didn’t help that the housing market was starting to slip, but by the time the place was ready to sell, buyers interested in a 3200 square-foot green home were scarce.

On the brighter side, the staff at Wright-Ryan quickly realized that the project was invaluable as an educational resource. It successfully served its original purpose as an in-house training exercise, but the benefits spread to more people than anticipated. Subcontractors and suppliers were challenged to try new things and set higher standards; local and regional organizations were exposed to new ideas; and countless students were given a first-hand look at sustainable home building in action.

General Specs and Team

Location: Freeport, ME
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2.5
Living Space: 3200
Cost: 230
Additional Notes:

Completed: 2006

Architect: Richard Renner
Builder/contractor: Wright-Ryan Construction

Construction

Foundation: 4-inch concrete slab, ICF walls (R-23)
Floors: 9-1/2-inch I-joists at 24 in. o.c.; 5-1/2-inch formaldehyde-free fiberglass batts between (R-21)
Walls: 2x6 studs at 24 in. o.c., dense-pack cellulose insulation (R-21)

Windows: Fiberglass frame, triple-pane, argon filled, low-e (U-factor=.15, R-6.7, Thermotech)
Roof: 9-1/2-inch I-joist rafters at 24 in. o.c.; loose-fill cellulose in ceiling (R-49)
Garage: Attached; ventilation fan activated by garage-door openers

Energy

  • Majority of lighting fixtures are fluorescent
  • Excess solar hot water assists radiant heating system
  • Building and window oriented for passive solar heating, daylighting, and ventilation

Energy Specs

Heating/cooling: evacuated-tube solar hot-water supplemented by high-efficiency propane boiler (Buderus); closed combustion fireplace for backup heat; HRV (Lifebreath); no air conditioning

Water heating: evacuated-tube solar hot-water system supplemented by high-efficiency propane boiler (Buderus)

HERS index: 42

Annual energy use: Home unoccupied—data to come

Water Efficiency

  • Low-flow showerheads, faucets, and toilets (Mansfield EcoQuantum dual-flush)
  • Drought-resistant turf
  • Indigenous plants

Indoor Air Quality

  • Low-VOC paint throughout
  • Formaldehyde-free materials (fiberglass insulation)
  • Garage ventilation fan activated by garage-door openers
  • No carpets (hardwood and tile floors throughout)
  • Green Materials and Resource Efficiency

    • FSC-certified lumber
    • Advanced framing techniques
    • Wheatcore doors, Dakota Burl cabinet panels

    • Recycled-content floor tile
    • Fly ash in concrete
    • Recycled-content metal roofing
    • Cellulose insulation
    • Locally sourced birch flooring, stair parts, framing lumber, cedar siding, and granite countertops

    Alternate Energy Utilization

    PV: 2-kW, grid-tied

    Certification

    LEED for Homes: Platinum (95/130 points)

    5 Comments

    1. Coleen Chrencik | | #1

      Greenblock Insulated Concrete Forms
      You could have enhanced the sustainability and increased wall R-Value to 30 or better if you had used Greenblock - Insulated Concrete forms. Reduced your HVAC requirements - our block is 4-hour fire rated - saved up to 70% in monthly utility costs and our walls can withstand 200+MPH winds.

      Good job - but you could have gone Greener.

    2. Jeff LeBlanch | | #2

      energy saving homes
      nobody really cares or will bother to buy one of these so quit waisting your time, GOD!

    3. Dan | | #3

      Sold
      It actually sold quite a while ago, Jeff, and it's a very cool house. Lovely snarky comments - makes the internet such a nice place.

    4. User avater GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #4

      Sale details
      Jeff and Dan,
      The sale eventually occurred, but it took a while. A real estate consultant convinced the developers that the market wouldn’t accept a small, modest home. Originally offered at $1.1 million, the 3,200-square-foot house languished on the market for 18 months before it was sold for $895,000.

    5. Frank Hanlan | | #5

      Re: .12 Air Changes per Hour !!!
      Living in the Edmonton, AB the insulation levels look barely better than our weak building standards, but .12 air changes per hour (ACH) is GREAT! Sealing the building envelope is key to building a low energy or net zero house. Peter Amerongen of Habitat Workshop and Studio Ltd. in Edmonton, AB believes that they need to keep their net zero or near net zero houses below .75 ACH. If anyone is interested in seeing a presentation by Peter on Jan. 13th and Feb. 22nd please check http://www.solaralberta.ca/seminars.php . There is also a presentation of an interesting retrofit of a 4 plex in Regina, SK done by Harold Orr - dated March 10th.

    Log in or create an account to post a comment.

    Community

    Recent Questions and Replies

    • |
    • |
    • |
    • |