GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter X Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Picture icon Hamburger Icon Close Icon Sorted

Community and Q&A

Thermal Comfort of Radiators vs. Minisplits in Leaky House

1910duplex | Posted in General Questions on

Minisplit comfort in leaky house zone 4a

Hi,

I was able to go from about 5200 at neg 50 cfm to 4200 at neg 50 cfm by doing closed-cell foam flash and batt in my attic a few years ago. Finished area of the house is 1272 sq ft, but there is an unfinished basement and the walk-up attic. The recent analyst said the CFM is 13 per hour at that 4,200 leakiness number.

I had a 24,000 BTU hyperheat Daikin installed for the upstairs, but have not used it much for heating at all since all we have downstairs is radiators, so there were only a few nights where it seemed like it would be nice to have a little heat on but we wouldn’t be cold in the morning. It does seem to be able to warm up my North-facing room better than the radiator does. 🙂

The manual J for the upstairs done at the time said
Structure Btuh30468
area (ft²)599′
Volume (ft³)7490

I am going to have the rim joists airsealed with closed cell foam, and I am going to install an interior storm window on the one room that has an 100-year-old-plus original double-hung window that opens to an unconditioned little back porch area. (All the other windows have storm windows of various vintages; blower door guy said the ancient aluminum ones were actually more effective than the Larson Golds we bought four years ago)

My question is — with a house this leaky, do you think I could be as comfortable with floor mounted minisplits as I am with radiators? Our gas boiler is 1980s vintage, and I would like to get off gas eventually if possible. We have four radiators on the first floor currently, and the living room/dining room are open to each other, so I was guessing one where the radiators are in the living room and one in the kitchen would do the trick?

Or is my only option to change radiators to low-temperature radiators and get an air-to-water solution for the first floor? I know that’s much pricier.

GBA Prime

Join the leading community of building science experts

Become a GBA Prime member and get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

Replies

Log in or create an account to post an answer.

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |