When researchers look at the effectiveness of ventilation systems installed in new homes, what do they find? To some extent, the answer depends on what area of the country you’re talking about, but we can safely report that:
Let’s look three recent field studies: one in Washington, one in Florida, and one in California.
In 2014, six researchers — David Hales, Ken Eklund, Rick Kunkle, Michael Lubliner, Adria Banks, and Charlie Stevens — performed a field study of ventilation systems in 29 homes in the Pacific Northwest. Their report, “A Field Study of Ventilation System Effectiveness in Low Air Leakage Residences,” is available online.
The systems were pre-screened. The ventilation researchers only included systems that were able to meet the requirements of the ASHRAE 62.2 standard. So right off the bat, a lot of ventilation systems were excluded, simply because they weren’t properly designed or installed.
The 29 homes included a variety of systems, including exhaust-only systems, central-fan-integrated supply ventilation systems, HRV systems, and ERV systems.
Here’s a key finding of the study: Most of the occupants of these homes didn’t know how to operate or maintain their ventilation system.
The researchers wrote, “The fact that over 90% of the occupants were satisfied with their system performance and indoor air quality even though over half of them did not have enough knowledge to operate or maintain the system is troubling, especially where the lack of knowledge correlates with unresolved operation and maintenance issues found by the WSU [Washington State University] Energy Program field staff. It means that occupant satisfaction is not a good indicator of ventilation system performance. Further, if something was seriously wrong with the system, the home occupant would probably be unable to recognize it or take appropriate action. Problems found on initial audit included controls not set to…