Calculating Heating Loads: EnergyPlus vs. Manual J
Background: I am trying to model the heating and cooling loads for my future home using EnergyPlus. I want to investigate different building construction methods and window options that would allow us to build a pretty-good house (https://www.prettygoodhouse.org/).
But I am an EnergyPlus beginner, so I wanted to verify my results using a CoolCalc Manual J prediction of heating and cooling loads. I tried to match the size and construction in the two approaches as closely as possible.
Parameters: The climate zone is 5A, and the home is 2000 square feet over two floors. The first floor is a walk-out basement, and about 50% of the walls are below ground. The estimated R values are: walls R30, roof R66, basement walls R20, basement slab R10. Assuming 2-pane windows with U 0.34.
Problem: My EnergyPlus model matches the cooling loads of CoolCalc pretty closely (11124 BTU/h from eplus versus 13189 BTU/h from CoolCalc), but the heating loads do not match at all: EnergyPlus predicts 12905 BTU/h versus CoolCalc’s 23890 BTU/h.
Question: Is a manual J prediction expected to over predict heating loads by this much, or should I suspect an issue with my use of EnergyPlus? More to the point, does 12905 BTU/h seem right for a home of this size and insulation in 5A?
GBA Detail Library
A collection of one thousand construction details organized by climate and house part