building-scienceheader image
0 Helpful?

The Lipstick-on-a-Pig Million-Dollar Home Syndrome

Despite spending large sums of money, owners of expensive homes often get cheapo HVAC systems

Posted on Oct 16 2013 by Allison A. Bailes III, PhD

I wonder about a lot of things. I wonder what life would be like if gravity were stronger. I wonder why Americans don't dance more. I wonder why so many people who can afford million-dollar homes get cheapo HVAC(Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning). Collectively, the mechanical systems that heat, ventilate, and cool a building. systems. That last one bugs me more more than the first two, by the way. It weighs on my mind because cheapo HVAC seems so out of step with the rest of a million-dollar home.

Certainly, some expensive homes get HVAC systems appropriate to their class, but I've seen and heard of so many contrary examples that homes with high-quality HVAC are probably in the minority. Here are five examples I've seen, either in person, in the media, or through others in our field.

Exhibit 1: Ductopus in a $3.4-million home

Martin Holladay, the Energy Nerd here at GBAGreenBuildingAdvisor.com, came to Georgia earlier this year, so I took him to see the green community, Serenbe. On our way back, I drove him by the Atlanta White House, and it just so happened that the house across the street, built by the same home builder, was having an open house. It was built for $3.4 million, one of the real estate agents said, but was listed at a mere $2.49 million. What a deal!

After exploring the lavish finishes upstairs, we discovered two mechanical rooms in the basement and the ductopus above is from the first one. The other had a ductopus, too, but not quite as impressive as this one. (And yes, that's 6 mil poly on the basement walls. In Atlanta. They put it on the attic-side of kneewalls in the two bonus rooms, too.)

Exhibit 2: Pretty — but ineffective — flex ducts in a 10,000-square-foot home

In photo 2 below, you can see a mass of flex duct that one person on the Energy Vanguard Facebook page compared to the CERN particle accelerator. Yeah, the installers made it look pretty, but guess what — those ducts all go to the master suite, which is one of the least comfortable areas in the house.

The master bath gets too hot in winter and too cold in summer (i.e., too much air). The master bedroom gets too hot in summer and too cold in winter (i.e., not enough air). They should have designed and commissioned the system properly. A good design probably would have specified trunklines instead of all those individual ducts, and the air flow would have been much better.

Exhibit 3: Crappy flex install in a spray-foamed home

In photo 3 below, the proud fellow, Deep Deshpande, is standing in the home he's having built. It's his dream home in Brookline, Massachusetts. The Wall Street Journal recently published an article about affluent home buyers getting their own jumbo construction loans to do just as Mr. Deshpande has done. Usually, they hire a home builder to build the home, but if you look at that photo, you'll see a mistake that's common even in million-dollar homes.

See all that flex duct? That's Walmart-style. Wait, I think I'm being too generous. It's probably more like Big Lots or Dollar General-style.

I can't see much of the duct system in that photo, but I can see enough to tell me that they may well end up with comfort problems.

  • The bundle of flex duct behind Mr. Deshpande is strapped a little tightly. 
  • If they're running three ducts in the same direction, why didn't they use a trunkline?
  • Worst of all, they ran flex duct in the roofline.

It's a shame that they've done this, too, because they used spray foam insulation in the walls and roofline. Someone obviously cared a bit about making the house comfortable and efficient, but as usual, that didn't apply to the duct system.

Exhibit 4: Panned rafter return ducts

This one blows my mind. They're using a pair of rafter cavities in a vaulted ceiling as a return duct in this 9,000-square-foot, $1.5-million-dollar home in Kentucky. The building code, at least in some areas, does allow you to use building cavities for return air, but running that return air right next to the roof deck is just stupid. That little bit of bubble wrap isn't going to help a lot, and there's no evidence of any sealing there either.

The real mind-blowing part, though, is that PVC pipe running through "duct." At first, I thought maybe it was going to be part of the condensate line, but Jamie Clark, who sent me the photo, told me it's part of the attic ventilation system. Notice that there's another one in one of the bays to the right. Hmmmm. I wonder how effective that will be at moving air from soffit vents to the ridge vent.

Exhibit 5: Atmospheric combustion inside the building enclosure

See that furnace in photo 5? If you know anything about HVAC systems, you'll recognize immediately that the furnace you're looking at is a standard efficiency (80%), atmospheric combustion model. (In case you're wondering, the flue was intentionally disconnected and won't be left this way.) The problem here is that it's in a million-dollar house with a million-dollar view on a beautiful lake. Why would anyone do this?

In addition to an atmospheric combustion, low-efficiency furnace just not fitting in, there's also the problem of it being an atmospheric combustion furnace. They've put it in a mechanical room in the basement in this house, which means that room will have to be isolated from the rest of the house, and that probably wasn't done well when they finished the house. Code also requires two big holes in the house to bring combustion air into that room. (Read more about the problems of atmospheric combustion inside the house.) The home in Exhibit 2 above also had 80% furnaces and natural draft water heaters in the basement.

Why do so many expensive homes get Walmart-class HVAC?

Sadly, this problem is all too common. The big expensive homes always get the fancy finishes. They often get the hot, green products as well: spray foam insulation, tankless water heaters, ground-source (a.k.a. geothermal) heat pumps... If they're putting in a forced-air HVAC system, though, they usually get crap for a distribution system.

Whose fault is this? It's hard to say in general, but here's a list of some of the main culprits:

  • HVAC contractor. They did the work, so they have to bear at least some of the responsibility. Still, good ones will walk away from jobs where they think they'll have to compromise too much, leaving that work to the companies that don't know how or don't care to install high-quality HVAC systems.
  • Home builder. They hire the HVAC contractor to fit the budget. A cheapo budget gets cheapo HVAC, so they need to adjust their budgets for HVAC.
  • Architect. Million-dollar homes usually have architects, who often have little understanding of the importance of HVAC. I spoke earlier this year with an architect who's done work on expensive homes, and he said they rarely include HVAC as part of their design because it's too hard to sell the client on it.
  • Homeowner / buyer. For many, the obsession with granite countertops, or whatever the latest finish fad is, dooms the HVAC system to Walmart-class. This applies to spec homes as well as those built on contract. Mostly, though, it's because they don't understand how much more comfortable a home with high-class HVAC can be.

In the ideal case, all of these parties work together as a team, along with the HVAC designer and the other trades whose work affects the performance of the home. I know that not a single home is ever built to the ideal case, but we could certainly do a lot better.

Allison Bailes of Decatur, Georgia, is a speaker, writer, energy consultant, RESNET-certified trainer, and the author of the Energy Vanguard Blog. You can follow him on Twitter at @EnergyVanguard.


Tags: , , , , ,

Image Credits:

  1. Martin Holladay
  2. Energy Vanguard
  3. Bob O'Connor - Wall Street Journal
  4. Jamie Clark, Climate Control, Lexington, Kentucky

1.
Oct 16, 2013 10:37 PM ET

Edited Oct 17, 2013 10:45 AM ET.

editing to an A minus... Losing the minus if ever rewritten
by aj builder, Upstate NY Zone 6a

Rewrite this without mentioning Walmart Walmart Walmart... Etc. Terrible piece of writing. Stick to designing HVAC maybe.

The f was a bit extreme... Must of been the politics of late influencing me.


2.
Oct 17, 2013 6:17 AM ET

Edited Oct 17, 2013 6:32 AM ET.

Great article
by Martin Holladay

Allison,
Thanks for another great blog.

To AJ: In this article, Allison provides important advice to HVAC contractors, builders, architects, and homeowners, and he illustrates his advice with photos and anecdotes based on his job-site observations. While GBA welcomes feedback from readers, one can't help wondering why you spend so much time on a web site that (to judge from the volume of your negative comments) apparently irks you.


3.
Oct 17, 2013 9:09 AM ET

Martin, I have started to
by Nick T - 6A (MN)

Martin, I have started to notice the same thing...

Great articles/blogs - as always! Keep it up everyone!


4.
Oct 17, 2013 10:41 AM ET

Edited Oct 18, 2013 9:26 AM ET.

Well...Some building info
by aj builder, Upstate NY Zone 6a

Well.... Some building info is very useful Martin..... This blog is useful but very poorly overseen by GBA staff as to style. Should have emailed your editor and Allison.... Instead of posting.... My bad. Who do I email next time? Where do you list email addresses?

Love to see this rewritten without the use of the negative Walmart/Dollar Store angle and the lipstick..... Title.... Not very professional writing IMO.... For a site like GBA.

The best content GBA has informs us how to... Cost... Details.... Not just ripping which is why I am ripping. Same with my Czech rip.... That blog didn't consider how limited the Chech home is.... Green Buildings ... Sustainability means low maintenance among other primary attributes... Looks nice matters only if the rest matters much more. That point was clearly missed .

IMHO.... :)

Give me an an editor's email... And keep my emails private and I can critique less via posting .

With a rewrite I would give this blog a passing grade.

So positives.... Martin ... Thumbs up.... Dana... Great .... Will work on being Mr. Nice guy for a day or two... Thanks for noting my disposition..... ;)


5.
Oct 17, 2013 10:59 AM ET

Edited Oct 17, 2013 11:02 AM ET.

Response to AJ
by Martin Holladay

AJ,
I see that you have edited your comment -- that one that awarded Allison an F minus -- and that you now award him an A minus, while still labeling his blog a "terrible piece of writing." Hmmm.

Anyone who wants to contact me can send me an e-mail:
martin [at] greenbuildingadvisor [dot] com.


6.
Oct 17, 2013 2:04 PM ET

Response to aj builder
by Allison A. Bailes III, PhD

I have no intention to rewrite what you think of as a "terrible piece of writing" to remove the Walmart/Dollar General analogy that you find so offensive. The lipstick-on-a-pig part of the title is a common idiom, and I don't know why you have a problem it. If you don't think this article meets your stylistic criteria, perhaps you should start your own blog. Maybe if it's good enough, you'll even be able to write for GBA some day.


7.
Oct 17, 2013 6:15 PM ET

HVAC isn't the only Lipstick
by Brian Godfrey

HVAC isn't the only Lipstick on a Pig thing in expensive houses. My wife and I planned a major remodel, so first we went to look at some $million+ houses to get an idea of what is popular. What we found was a development of hundreds of houses all built from three basic floorplans. They were larger than the average American house, but not gigantic. The lack of quality was appalling. The lack of any craftsmanship or customization was appalling at that price. The kitchens were basically one corner of a great room with an L layout of counters and wall cabinets and a pretty good sized island. The faces were flat, plain particle board with some synthetic facing to make them look like dark stained cherry. The drawers were clanky steel. Just amazing. I'm sticking to old houses from now on. Besides, buying used is certainly greener than the consumption of buying new.


Register for a free account and join the conversation


Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!