Boston Mulls a New Template for Urban Housing
A collaborative pitches small modular housing as a way to align the city's housing stock with what residents need
A Boston startup is proposing a new housing model designed to solve a fundamental problem with urban apartments — they're too big.
The company, Livelight, and architect Tamara Roy developed a model for very small modular apartments that can be racked in steel-framed exoskeletons on small infill lots, expanding housing opportunities for one- and two-person urban households. The project also had the backing of the Boston Society of Architects.
Livelight founder Addison Godine said he was approached by the Mayor's Housing Innovation Lab and asked to design a micro-apartment on wheels. He and Roy, then the incoming president of the Boston Society of Architects, rolled up their sleeves and developed a prototype called the Urban Housing Unit, or uhü, and submitted the design in a competition for development of a city-owned lot in Boston's Roxbury neighborhood.
"Among many initiatives one of their interests was compact living spaces as a potential partial solution to the housing crunch that was happening in Boston," Godine said of the Innovation Lab in a telephone interview. "There is a great mismatch between the housing stock and the citizenry — 17% of the housing stock in Boston is studio and one-bedrooms but 67% of Boston city residents are one- and two-person households.”
Their 385-square-foot prototype, built at a modular factory in Pennsylvania, was parked for its introductory exhibition at City Hall Plaza last August and has since been trucked to eight different sites around Boston. Thousands of people have taken the tour, and sometime this spring, the city is due to decide whether Godine can move forward with a proposal to rack seven units on the Roxbury property and put them on the market.
Boston is one of a number of cities looking at very small dwelling units as a way of making affordable housing more available (see "Cities Think Small to Ease the Housing Crunch" in the sidebar below).
People needed to see the real thing
The city had been touring neighborhoods to talk about the potential of more compact housing and micro-apartments, Godine said, but more often than not the reaction was a blank stare. Staffers from the Innovation Lab tried marking the outline of a micro-apartment on a gym floor with blue painter's tape, for example, in order to give prospective tenants an idea of what living in one would be like. It just wasn't clicking.
“It didn’t really communicate what a space could be like," he said, "so they said what we really want to do is build a real one.”
He and Roy were both familiar with little houses. Godine managed the 2011 Solar Decathlon team while a student at Middlebury College, a role that encouraged the study of small, unconventional residential spaces. Later, he worked for a company called Getaway that placed tiny houses in rural settings and rented them to city people. Roy had lived in a 300-square-foot apartment in the Netherlands with her husband and their baby while earning her master's degree, and has become a widely known advocate for micro-apartments since then. She's now a principal at Stantec, where her bio says she's been nicknamed the "mother of the micro-unit."
Once Roy knew she was in line to take over the Boston Society of Architects, she saw an opportunity to promote a favorite theme.
"I knew that I had this once-in-a-lifetime chance to put some of the ideas we have for making more efficient smaller units and getting the word out there that they weren’t going to be tenements or old boarding houses," she said. "We could show it was really a solution that was going to meet the demand that people in smaller household sizes have in Boston.”
She lined up a meeting with Godine, and they soon decided to join forces and respond to the request-for-proposal from the city. The pair decided modular made the most sense for the apartment prototype, and they contacted a number of factories before settling on PennKraft Building Systems in Pennsylvania.
Once the uhü was delivered, the tours began. What the 3,000 or so visitors saw was a long, boxy structure with a kitchen, a code-compliant bathroom, a sleeping alcove, a living/dining area that could seat six for dinner, and a variety of storage shelves and lockers — all in a package much better insulated and air-sealed than a typical city dwelling.
A video narrated by Roy at the Livelight website runs through the basics.
According to Godine, only 2% of those who toured the uhü said it wasn't for them or wouldn't fit in their particular neighborhoods. Others expressed "some range of bewilderment" about the project but not necessarily a negative view. A number of visitors said they were familiar with the idea of micro-apartments because of television coverage of tiny houses.
What comes in the package
The uhü is 13 feet 10 inches wide, 33 feet long, and 11 feet tall — something like half of a conventional single-wide manufactured home. Including the trailer, it weighs 20,000 pounds.
Exterior walls are framed with 2x8s and insulated with R-31 fiberglass batts. Both the floor and the roof are framed with 12-inch I-joists and insulated with fiberglass. (The roof also has a layer of rigid foam insulation.) Godine estimated nominal R-values of 40 in the floor and between 50 and 55 in the roof. Windows are double-pane Marvin Integrity.
CladdingMaterials used on the roof and walls to enclose a house, providing protection against weather. for the prototype is a translucent polycarbonate material called Polygal, which allows the uhü to glow at night. If it were ever to be put into production, Godine said, it could have siding more appropriate for an urban property — something like fiber cement.
The uhü is heated and cooled with a single-head Mitsubishi Hyper-Heat ductless minisplit with a rated capacity of 18,000 BtuBritish thermal unit, the amount of heat required to raise one pound of water (about a pint) one degree Fahrenheit in temperature—about the heat content of one wooden kitchen match. One Btu is equivalent to 0.293 watt-hours or 1,055 joules. . Godine said the unit is capable of producing heat with outside temperatures as low as -23°F. It also comes with a Nest thermostat, just so residents don't squander the chance to save energy.
The design also includes Intello, a membrane used for airtightness and vapor control. There was, however, no money in the budget for a blower-door testTest used to determine a home’s airtightness: a powerful fan is mounted in an exterior door opening and used to pressurize or depressurize the house. By measuring the force needed to maintain a certain pressure difference, a measure of the home’s airtightness can be determined. Operating the blower door also exaggerates air leakage and permits a weatherization contractor to find and seal those leakage areas..
It cost $85,000, including the trailer, all furniture, and all appliances. Godine would like to see the cost to drop to between $40,000 and $50,000.
Reaction 'mixed' at neighborhood roll-out
Godine's plan, should he win the city's OK, would be to stack a total of seven units in a three-story steel rack on the Roxbury lot (see the second to last image below) and put them up for sale. The studios would sell for $149,000 and the two-bedroom units — expanded versions of the prototypical uhü 52 feet long and measuring 621 square feet — would sell for $199,000.
The steel rack is what Godine calls pallet rack framing, just as you'd see in Home Depot or any distribution warehouse. "The idea," he said, "is you can slot in your uhü or whatever, much like boats slot into a marina."
One problem yet to be overcome is the city's current minimum size requirement for dwellings. Studio apartments must be a minimum of 450 square feet; one-bedrooms must be 625 square feet.
"You have to get around that somehow," Godine said. "My company thinks you shouldn't have to get around it. You should just be able to build this small because, really, there's no problem with it."
Another potential problem is public acceptance of a design that's more contemporary than its surroundings. Godine said the Roxbury proposal recently was the subject of a public presentation in the neighborhood and got a "mixed" reaction.
"The question is whether they want this kind of design in their neighborhood at all," Godine said. "It's a fairly conservative neighborhood, and this many be rocking the boat with something contemporary looking."
- Live Light
Feb 1, 2017 10:13 AM ET
Feb 2, 2017 12:42 PM ET
Feb 2, 2017 1:27 PM ET