Helpful? 0

How to Keep the Noise Down

What's the best approach for sound-proofing bedrooms?

Posted on Nov 8 2010 by Scott Gibson

A teen whose musical tastes run to head-pounding heavy metalMetallic elements with high atomic weights, including mercury, lead, cadmium, arsenic, and chromium. Released as industrial pollutants, some heavy metals are toxic and may accumulate to hazardous levels in the food chain. Different from Heavy Metal, which is a type of music frequently heard on job sites. classics? Uncle Ted, whose snoring would wake the dead? Who knows what's giving Robert Car pause for thought. Whatever it is, he wants to build in some effective sound-proofing.

“I'm aware of using more than one layer of drywall,” he writes in Q&A post, “but is that the only way?”

Increase the mass of the wall
Car is reluctant to add a second layer of gypsum drywall mainly because it will, however slightly, reduce the usable space in the room.

But increased mass is part of an effective strategy for reducing sound transmission.

“Here are some good rules of thumb,” writes Robert Riversong. "When the mass of a barrier is doubled, the isolation quality (or STC rating) increases by approximately 5 dB, which is clearly noticeable. Installing insulation within a wall or floor/ceiling cavity will improve the STC rating by about 4 to 6 dB. An airspace of 1-1/2 in. will improve the STC by approximately 3 dB. An airspace of 3 in. will improve the STC by approximately 6 dB.”

A second layer of drywall, often 5/8 in. rather than 1/2 in. thick, along with resilient channel to isolate the drywall from the wall framing, increases mass and reduces sound transmission. Andy Ault, however, suggests three other options.

These are: Celotex SoundStop (a sound-proofing fiberboard), QuietRock by Serious Materials, and something called Soundproofing Mass Loaded Vinyl, manufactured by Super Soundproofing Co.

“We practically make this our [standard operating procedure] in walls between master baths and nurseries/adjoining bedrooms,” Ault writes of SoundStop. “We bond the SoundStop to the framing using an acoustical sealant running horizontal to the framing. Then we tape the joints with butyl tape. Next, we layer the gyp board over that in a vertical orientation. It's quick, easy, and relatively cheap and gets very high marks from our clients.”

Pricey options are unnecessary
Some of the products Ault has used are expensive in comparison with conventional drywall, and the added cost may not be worth it, says Ted White.

He calls SoundStop “another generic ‘sound board.’ Soundboard does not decouple, has very little mass, and is too dense for proper absorption,” White says. “Also, the very limited if nonexistent acoustic data makes this product all but abandoned by the acoustic community.”

In apparent reference to Ault's next step up, QuietRock, White says that any "pre-damped" drywall will perform well, and at a lower cost. “You will always be able to field-assemble your own board using standard 5/8-in. drywall and a damping compound,” he says. “The resulting wall will be half the cost, and much higher performance.”

Finally, the massloaded vinyl (which can cost as much as $3.25/sq. ft). "is simply mass," White adds. "Drywall is mass, plywood is mass, etc. Mass is mass. At $1-plus a square foot, you're better off using standard drywall from Home Depot."

And if you're going to add a second layer of drywall, he adds, don't forget to use a product called Green Glue to further dampen sound transmission.

Insulation helps, too
GBA Advisor Michael Chandler's approach is to cover one side of the wall with a 1/8-in. layer of structural cardboard sheathingMaterial, usually plywood or oriented strand board (OSB), but sometimes wooden boards, installed on the exterior of wall studs, rafters, or roof trusses; siding or roofing installed on the sheathing—sometimes over strapping to create a rainscreen. called ThermoPly and spray the back with an inch of open-cell polyurethane foam.

"We generally do this on the 'noisy side' of the wall, especially in laundry rooms and bathrooms," Chandler says. "The foam is a lousy sound emitter, and it helps seal up electrical openings and flanking paths."

He repeats advice given by Riversong, that potential pathways for sound transmission under doors and through ductwork and electrical outlets must be sealed. This is what he means by "flanking."

"Insulation in the stud bays definitely improves sound containment," writes Thomas Jefferson. "Denser is better, but even a standard fiberglass batt works." Denim batts, mentioned as a possible option by Car, is a good choice as well, he says.

"I think the highest-performing material would be mineral wool," says Jefferson, "e.g., Roxul or Thermafiber. Dense-packed cellulose would also work well and has the best green cred (lowest energy embodied, highest recycled content)."

White, however, says insulation in a single-stud wall does a good but not great job, mainly because sound transmission through the wall framing limits its effectiveness. He suggests blown-in cellulose or fiberglass if the walls have already been drywalled, and R-13 fiberglass batts if they are still open.

"Why? Because it works best in the low frequencies," says White. "Mineral fiber has a slight edge in the upper frequencies, but that wall will not have high-frequency issues. It will have low frequencies as the only significant frequency issue. Since fiberglass has the edge there, we use it."

Our expert's opinion
Here's the take of GBA technical director Peter Yost:

As with all areas of performance, managing sound requires the right blend of design, materials, and construction. You can’t purchase quiet; you need to get the science right first.

Sound is energy expressed as pressure variations in air. When sound strikes a material, it can be transmitted, reflected, or absorbed. To reduce sound transmission through building assemblies, there are three options:

1. Reduce transmission by reducing air leaks (flanking paths).

2. Reduce transmission by absorbing the vibrations with materials and/or spaces in the assemblies.

3. Capture or trap air vibrations with variegated surfaces on the noise-generating side of the assembly (to trap or capture means to absorb rather than reflect or transmit).

To seriously reduce sound transmission from room to room, you need to use all three options.

Flanking paths are addressed the same way we address them for energy efficiency (by air-sealing all gaps and installing weatherstripping on doors). But if the rooms have forced-air heating or cooling, configuration of duct runs may come into play.

Mass dissipates vibrational energy, but different materials can respond to different frequencies.

Variegated surfaces are materials such as corkboard, acoustical ceiling tiles, or conical foam cushion.

How you combine these techniques depends on the quality and the quantity of the sound transmission you are trying to block. If it’s a teenage rock band, you might have to move them to the basement to eliminate at least one plane of transmission, the floor.

I have never done any acoustical testing of building assemblies, so I rely on resources such as Architectural Acoustics: Principles and Design or the simpler and free "Classroom Acoustics", offered by the Noise Pollution Clearinghouse. Both include building assemblies with verified STC ratings.

The practical advice offered by White, Riversong, Chandler, and Ault seems reasonable. Just remember that individual materials don’t manage sound transmission, whole assemblies (wall, ceiling, and floor) do.


Tags: , , ,

Image Credits:

  1. Fine Homebuilding
1.
Wed, 11/10/2010 - 18:04

Sound proofing
by Mike Legge

Helpful? 2

What Does Work
Sheetrock is a prime material used in sound proofing interior walls, but it must be used in layers, using silicone caulking between them for maximum effect. The silicone itself performs as a sound dampener to retard vibration transfer. It is inexpensive so you can use it liberally.
• Apply a thick layer of silicone to all stud surfaces before applying the sheetrock. Use screws to attach the sheetrock to the walls as it allows you to create fewer holes than you would need to if using nails.
• Apply a second layer of sheetrock, using a thick coating of silicone in between. As previously mentioned, mass is important for sound proofing so the thicker the wall, the better it works.
As for space, the space in the wall cavity will have excellent sound proofing qualities because without having something solid to vibrate, the sound will dissipate into the empty space.
Using sheetrock when sound proofing interior walls is efficient and inexpensive and doesn't take up a lot of room. It is a permanent solution that won't need repairing or maintenance and you can decorate it to suit the appearance of the room. Remember windows, skylights, doors and floorboards when sound proofing a room because they will potentially be the downfall in your efforts. Depending on just how sound proof you want or need the room to be, they will be fairly important considerations in your master plan.

Is this use of silicone justifiable? Thank you for the valuable information that you always give. Cheers Mike Legge


2.
Wed, 11/10/2010 - 18:53

Sound proofing rooms
by Cathy Rust

Helpful? -6

We live in a semi and can hear the bass of our neighbour's alarm clock and some heavy nightly snoring. We ripped out the baseboard and added acoustical sealant, and spray foamed around the outlets. We can still hear a little bit. I was wondering if another layer of 5/8" standard drywall (Certainteed), plus Green Glue would help eliminate the low frequency noise. I'd appreciate any suggestions you might have.


3.
Wed, 11/10/2010 - 21:49

RC1 channel in drawing
by Anonymous

Helpful? -6

the RC1 channel is depicted inncorectly. It is upside down.


4.
Thu, 11/11/2010 - 17:52

Damping Materials in Drywall Assemblies
by BobboMax

Helpful? -8

11/11/10

As someone said, it's not the components, it's the assembly.

Ref Mike's suggestion of silicone, I'd go w/ GreenGlue- it's specifically designed to remain viscous and to be a damping material, whereas silicone is designed as a sealant.. I haven't heard of using GG against studs, but that doesn't seem unreasonable. Definitely between first and second sheet of drywall.

Ref Cathy's question about GreenGlue, go for it- it may not cure your problem, but it's by far the simplest potential solution. I'd consider pulling your existiing outlet boxes and installing old-work boxes that only engage the second (damped) layer of drywall. (Or consider deleting the boxes in that wall.) If you want to get fancier, consider blowing cellulose into the stud cavities- the second layer of drywall will cover the holes. And if you really want to get fancy, install RC1 horizontally across the studs, then add another layer or two of drywall. Do check out the GreenGlue site concerning the potential two-cavity problem. They may advise against creating 2 cavities (studs, then RC1.)


5.
Thu, 11/11/2010 - 20:22

Acoustical sealant options
by TJ Elder

Helpful? 3

Green Glue has apparently been successful marketing their product, but there is a less expensive option with even greater name recognition: Sheetrock brand acoustical sealant. The point being this can be a generic item (non hardening sealant) and shouldn't come at a large price premium.

Also, to address Mike's comment above: even with plenty of mass, it's not sufficient for sound to "dissipate" into empty space inside a wall. For an effective barrier to sound transmission, there should be sound absorbing material (fiberglass, rockwool, etc) to convert acoustic energy into heat. A few inches of air will not effectively absorb sound energy and it will pass from surface to surface across an assembly. Even a masonry cavity wall gains several STC points with acoustic insulation in the middle.


6.
Fri, 11/12/2010 - 01:33

GG vs. Sheetrock Acoustical Sealant
by BobboMax

Helpful? 1

Thomas,

Green Glue is different than an acoustical sealant, whose job is to eliminate holes in the barrier, "sound-sealing partitions at gaps, electrical box cutouts," "It dries to a tough but flexible film, forming a long-lasting, resilient, acoustical seal." (Quotes are from http://www.usg.com/sheetrock-acoustical-sealant.html ) If I remember my acoustics, a 10% hole can transmit 90% of the sound energy. (That's a simplistic generalization, of course.)

Green Glue, on the other hand, is a visco-elastic damping material which is applied to the surface of the second sheet of drywall, like Jackson Pollock or a kid putting syrup on a pancake. Then the sheet is slapped against the first layer and fastened w/ longer screws. It's a mildly messy process, although I've done it in a carpeted apartment- I only had to grab the mineral spirits a couple of times.. It's also available in a ready-made drywall/GG/drywall sandwich.

Imagine putting honey on yuor hands and trying to rub them together- your hands are the drywall, the honey is the GG. The sound waves flex the drywall sheets like a speaker cone and the GG is a shear interface- the sheets are trying to move relative to each other, the GG restrains them and absorbs the sound energy, converting it into heat, as you say. The added mass of the second sheet of drywall also helps w/ sound absorption- air is pretty light stuff and it has a hard time pushing something like drywall around.

Acoustic insulation sealants definitely help, but they don't disrupt "flanking paths," for example, studs, screws, outlet and light fixture holes and plumbing, which can transmit the sound energy directly from the receiver (the noisy side drywall) to the emitter (the quiet side drywall.) Think of the kid's "telephone," two Dixie cups w/ a string between their bottoms- the bottoms are the receiver and emitter, the string is the flanking path. Smear honey on the bottoms and it will damp the sound.

But don't take my word for it- go to the GG site http://www.greengluecompany.com/

And no, I don't work for GG- I took an acoustics course in engineering school, so I'm a trained professional now.


7.
Fri, 11/12/2010 - 07:29

Sound proofing
by Cathy Rust

Helpful? -6

Thanks everyone for your suggestions!


8.
Mon, 11/15/2010 - 09:37

Soundproofing floors
by ngb

Helpful? 2

I may have missed it, but what about sound proofing floors between floors in a two story house? The ceiling on the mainfloor is the wooden subfloor in our log house. The sound transmission between the two is amazing. Is there a material we could add to the second floor subfloor?

Thanks for all the suggestions.


9.
Mon, 11/15/2010 - 09:53

Response to NGB
by Martin Holladay, GBA Advisor

Helpful? 3

Here are two resources on floors -- from the "Related Content" box on this page:

Controlling the Transmission of Impact Sound through Floors

Quiet, Please


10.
Mon, 11/15/2010 - 13:57

Reducing noise within a room
by dbuelke

Helpful? -6

Most of the discussion centers around room-to-room sound attenuation, but I've been hard put to find information for practical and aesthetic methods of attenuating noise within rooms. Many homes have large great rooms with expansive windows and wood flooring and the internal echoing is disconcerting. We have an open kitchen/dining/family room with windows and flat surfaces that once was carpeted. However, kitchen carpeting went out a decade ago and after we replaced it with cork we can hardly carry on a conversation if there are dishes clanking in the kitchen.

Somewhere, somebody must have some methods, products, or designs that would help this situation, short of redesigning the whole building. I've seen where someone had hung sound blankets on their high ceilings and walls. It worked well, but is hardly aesthetic.


11.
Mon, 11/15/2010 - 14:15

Response to Dbuelke
by Martin Holladay, GBA Advisor

Helpful? 2

Dbuelke,
You are asking a legitimate question, and I hope a knowledgeable reader posts a useful suggestion soon.

In the meantime, I can't help savoring the delicious irony ... our great rooms are now so great that the inhabitants are wondering how to overcome the disadvantages of the huge echoing spaces they have bought. It reminds me of those interior scenes of Xanadu in Citizen Kane -- with the huge dining table and fireplace, and all those echoes...


12.
Mon, 11/15/2010 - 22:09

reducing noise in open concept room
by Noland

Helpful? 2

Acoustic panels that are covered in air brushed artwork with strategically placed throw rugs and cloth covered furniture can help to alleviate the echo effect in open concept rooms.


13.
Fri, 11/26/2010 - 19:20

STC ratings
by ecoralph.blogspot.com

Helpful? 2

Canada's NBC has a plethora of wall assemblies and their STC ratings.
I went for single-layer drywall on 3 5/8" steel studs for my bedroom walls, and added batt insulation for the laundry room.


14.
Tue, 05/28/2013 - 04:32

Putty pads
by Max Anthony

Helpful? 0

Don't forget acoustical putty pads for backing electrical outlet boxes before you fiberglass or sprayfoam. It helps a great deal as outlet boxes are like megaphones for sounds traveling between walls. You can also use putty pads to fill small voids inside a wall. I got a pack off of ebay for rather cheap.


Register for a free account and join the conversation


Get a free account and join the conversation!
Become a GBA PRO!