GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter X Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Picture icon Hamburger Icon Close Icon Sorted
Green Building Curmudgeon

Seeking the Elusive Grade 1 Batt Installation

I finally found insulation contractors capable of Grade 1 work — in the very competitive multifamily market

Seeing insulation of this quality practically brings tears of joy to my eyes. If only it happened more often.
View Gallery 5 images
Seeing insulation of this quality practically brings tears of joy to my eyes. If only it happened more often. With some coaching, we were able to get the project team to understand why and how chases such as these needed to be air sealed, and they got the work done. This chase was identified on site as not being properly air sealed. Batts were placed in the wall without the necessary air barrier. Finding these issues on site is critical to assuring a complete building envelope. This is the drawing of the chase pictured above. All our projects start with a detailed drawing review pointing out potential issues to both the architect and the contractor. The next step is to have the drawings include necessary details and for them to be incorporated on site. Although the installation on this project was generally excellent, there were still the occasional lapses. This cavity had the insulation properly split below the purlin, but not above.

Having spent much of my time writing for GBA whining and complaining about the state of the insulation industry, it is now time for me to eat a little crow. The insulation work at one of our multifamily certification projects has, amazingly, met – and even possibly exceeded – my expectations for quality.

After recently being fired from a certification project because we were being too demanding on the contractor, we were pleasantly surprised to find another client who was not only willing but eager to do high quality building envelope work. To meet NGBS certification through the prescriptive path, the project needed to meet the Grade 1 installation standard for insulation. Since the budget included fiberglass batt insulation, we raised our concerns early in the process, apparently with some success as the contractor found an installer who not only claimed to do Grade 1 work, but actually accomplished it.

The installers are proud of their work and it shows. The batts are consistently cut properly to fit the wall cavities, and are (mostly) split around wires and pipes. Interestingly, during a recent inspection, I pulled back some batts around plumbing drains to find the lower section split properly while the top section wasn’t. I find it hard to understand the thought process behind this type of inconsistency.

Air sealing is still a challenge

During our initial walk-through prior to the start of insulation, we identified several chases on each floor that required additional air sealing. The construction team was not aware of these energy code and NGBS requirements. Although the city building inspectors don’t seem to enforce them, we do.

The team installed drywall in the chases to provide the required air barrier. We recently invited the architects to meet with us on site to discuss some of the air sealing details, providing them feedback on how they can better document them on future projects.

The envelope, please

One of the issues we see in multifamily buildings is inconsistent definition and location of the building envelope.

Exterior walls are pretty straightforward, except for the assorted bump-outs that are typically only aesthetic. With few exceptions, the on-grade or elevated podium slabs generally define the bottom of the envelope.

Roofs vary from steep slope to flat, offering multiple opportunities for insulation location, and often creating complex kneewall conditions. We see flat roofs specified with deck insulation as the base for roofing (not intended to serve as thermal insulation), often with ceiling insulation specified – creating a sort of semi-conditioned attic that wastes much of the value of the roof deck insulation.

In one recent project, where the specified roof deck insulation was adequate as the thermal barrier, we recommended that the ceiling insulation be eliminated, creating a fully conditioned attic in the process. This detail did create some kneewalls that needed additional attention at cantilevers and against elevator shafts, but the overall results were better and less expensive than the original design.

Onward and upward

As our consulting and certification work on multifamily building expands, we continue to find new and interesting challenges that must be overcome for our clients to meet green certification. We see every challenge as an opportunity to improve building performance, learn something new, and help others figure out how to do a better job the next time.

One great thing about this business is that there are always new challenges, keeping us and our clients on our toes and our days interesting.


Log in or create an account to post a comment.



Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |