GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Audio Play Icon Headphones Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Picture icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon
Musings of an Energy Nerd

Two Wingnuts Describe Their Backyard Tape Tests

In tests performed by Peter Yost and Dave Gauthier, Huber’s Zip System tape outlasts Siga Wigluv and Tescon Vana

Wearing his trademark wingnut hat, Peter Yost explains his tape-testing methodology to Andy Shapiro and Martin Holladay at the BuildingEnergy 16 conference in Boston, Massachusetts.
Image Credit: Photo #1: Jerelyn Wilson

Regular visitors to GBA probably know that I’m a big fan of backyard product tests. (In the past, I’ve reported on my tape tests, flexible flashing tests, and liquid-applied flashing tests.) So when I noticed that Peter Yost and Dave Gauthier would be giving a presentation titled “Sticky Business: Tape Testing, Round Two” at the BuildingEnergy 16 conference in Boston, I showed up early to make sure I got a good seat.

Peter Yost is GBA’s technical director, while Dave Gauthier is a sales representative for Atlas EPS. The two backyard scientists conducted a series of tests in Yost’s shed (christened the “Wingnut Test Facility”); from my perspective, their light-hearted approach brings just the right amount of irreverence to these research efforts.

At the conference in Boston, Yost began by providing “context and caveats.” He pointed out that this was “pro bono work” — the two friends have no funding for their research, so expenses come out of their pockets.

“Our sample size is two,” Yost said. In other words, each test included only two samples of each tested product, which is “not statistically significant.” He noted, “Our tests are limited. We are not here to recommend a tape. We are not here to say, ‘This is the product to use.’”

A partial list of the ASTM test protocols that tape manufacturers can choose from.[/caption]

Lab testing vs. job-site testing

In theory, the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) should, by now, have developed some testing protocols for tapes used by residential and commercial builders. They have — sort of — but the standardized tests aren’t very relevant.

Yost explained that tape manufacturers can…

GBA Prime

This article is only available to GBA Prime Members

Sign up for a free trial and get instant access to this article as well as GBA’s complete library of premium articles and construction details.

Start Free Trial

8 Comments

  1. User avater
    Armando Cobo | | #1

    Wingnut hat
    Is hard to read this article after looking at Peter's picture... from the Red Mikey Mouse club? God Job!

  2. Lucy Foxworth | | #2

    Serious looks on their faces
    What gets me is that they all have such serious looks on their faces.

    But still, the article is informative. I think it actually makes an argument for plywood over OSB. It's a far more tapeable substrate.

  3. User avater GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay | | #3

    Response to Lucy Foxworth
    Lucy,
    In many cases, including with Siga Wigluv, the tape samples failed on the vinyl and aluminum window flanges before they failed on the OSB. So when it comes to acrylic tape tenacity, the OSB substrate may not be the issue here.

  4. Derek Roff | | #4

    Orientation of forces?
    Photo 7 indicates that the force of gravity is pulling parallel to the plane of the OSB, while photos 4, 5, and 6 seem to show gravity perpendicular to the OSB. OK, I just read the caption on photo 7. Was the orientation different only during the few seconds of spritzing with water? Was weight stressing the tape, during the spritzing?

  5. Kohta Ueno | | #5

    Wingnut Hat
    Hey Armando--the hat is one of these. I think it's a piece of Detroit Red Wings swag. http://hockeygods.com/system/gallery_images/1681/normal.jpg?1291329957

  6. User avater GBA Editor
    Peter Yost | | #6

    Orientation of forces?
    Hi Derek -

    We unload the 1-pound weights just before tipping up the OSB strips, then we spritz them front and back and then we lay the strips back down and reload the 1-pound weights.

  7. Derek Roff | | #7

    Thank you, Peter
    Thanks for helping me interpret what I was seeing in photo 7.

  8. User avater
    Brian Knight | | #8

    Product Availability
    I can understand 3m 8067 not being available but surprised you found stockyards supplying European products. We order 3m tape and Tescon tapes online and are delivered very quickly.
    If the primer had been allowed to develop its sticky tack, results would certainly have been different but agree messing with primer is a huge downside. I've found 8067 to be more sticky and flexible but less tolerant of long UV exposure. Based on my observations I would choose 8067 for everything except zip panel sheathing. Would love to see you add 8067 in the future to check my hunch.

Log in or become a member to post a comment.

Related

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |