GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Audio Play Icon Headphones Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Picture icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon
Musings of an Energy Nerd

Insulating Rim Joists

Use rigid foam or spray foam, not fiberglass or mineral wool

One way to insulate the interior side of a rim joist is with spray foam. It's also possible to use rectangles of rigid foam insulation in this location. Either approach is preferable to using fiberglass or mineral wool insulation. Although the illustration shows that the top of the foundation wall is uninsulated, a proper installation of spray foam would cover the top of the concrete wall. [Image credit: Fine Homebuilding]

Rim joists make up the perimeter of the floor system of a wood-framed house. Also known as band joists, rim joists are pieces of lumber—either sawn lumber or engineered lumber—that are installed vertically above the mudsill. On a new house, a typical rim joist might be a 2×10 or 2×12. Older houses have all kinds of different rim joists, including 2x6s, 2x8s, or even square timbers like 8x8s. Some older balloon-framed houses lack rim joists—instead, the bottom plates of the wall framing (or the studs) sit directly on the mudsill.

If you live in an older house, it’s important to check whether your rim joists are insulated. In a house with an unfinished basement or crawlspace, inspecting your rim joists should be easy. If your basement has a finished drywall or plaster ceiling, however, you’ll probably need to cut some inspection holes in the ceiling to inspect your rim joists.

Two-story homes usually have another ring of rim joists above the first-floor ceiling. If you need to insulate this type of rim joist, it’s best to hire a cellulose-insulation contractor. (To learn more about the “grain bag” method that cellulose contractors use to insulate rim joists, see “How to Install Cellulose Insulation.”)

Why do we insulate rim joists?

If your rim joist is uninsulated, the only layers between the rim joist and the outdoors are the sheathing, which is typically between ½ in. and ¾ in. thick, the asphalt felt or housewrap, and the siding. Rim joists are above grade, so it makes sense to insulate them to the same level as above-grade walls—a minimum of R-13 in climate zones 1 through 4, or a minimum of R-20 in climate zones 5 though 8.

These days, rim-joist insulation is required by most building codes; in the 2018 International…

GBA Prime

This article is only available to GBA Prime Members

Sign up for a free trial and get instant access to this article as well as GBA’s complete library of premium articles and construction details.

Start Free Trial

81 Comments

  1. Phil LaMoreaux | | #1

    This is a great article that addresses many of the complicating issues facing a seemingly simple issue. The last section touches on the risk of insulating an older home without a capillary break under the mudsill. I'd like to add to the discussion with a caution for stick framed homes built prior to the common use of pressure treated mud sills (1980s?). While the current code does require PT lumber when that element is in contact with concrete, many homes were built with KD mud sills. In my opinion this magnifies the risk of eliminating the inward drying potential associated with installing rigid foam or spray foam. The sad truth of our current housing stock is that there multiple failure points in exterior drainage planes that have the potential to allow the intrusion of bulk water. In my experience, the most common places we see this is around entry doors where drip lines splash back on entry door systems and the surrounding siding and poorly detailed window sills without kickout flashings. These allow bulk water to run down to the wall to the sill assembly. Capillary action pulls water into the joint between the foundation and mud sill. If we eliminate the inward drying potential, we may unknowingly be inviting structural repairs involving mud sill and rim band replacements. This type of rot, left unattended can get into the ends of floor joists, which is much bigger challenge to repair.
    In an ideal world, sill seal, PT mud sills and excellent detailing of the exterior drainage plane would make these concerns mute. For those of us dealing with existing housing stock, it may be worth spending a little time outside with and IR camera, looking for signs of moisture before recommending foam insulation in a non PT mudsill assembly.

    1. Phil LaMoreaux | | #6

      Thinking about this objectively would involve comparing the net savings from the insulation with the cost of repairing an assembly that is currently functioning times some arbitrary risk factor for homes built this way. In situations like these, the energy savings from the installation can come at a cost to the resilience of the current structure and that does have an economic impact to consider.

  2. Expert Member
    Carl Seville | | #2

    Martin - regarding your section showing spray foam extending down to the foundation, in termite prone regions, it is often required to leave an inspection gap to make sure they don't build tunnels behind the foam and eat the framing.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #5

      Carl,
      You're right, of course. Thanks for the reminder.

  3. Tyler Keniston | | #3

    "If you need to insulate [the second floor] type of rim joists, it’s best to hire a cellulose-insulation contractor."

    Doesn't this sort of go against all the advice given for the bottom rim joist? What's different (other than possibly access)? Or are we considering the bag/cellulose method to provide adequate air and vapor retardancy? (or is it proximity to the foundation?...)
    If it's simply a matter of access and working with what we've got, then are the condensation concerns raised here sort of just ignored in hopes that the theory won't manifest as a reality?

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #4

      Tyler,
      In the case of rim joists between the first floor and the second floor, there is a robust air barrier -- usually plaster or drywall -- between the interior air and the rim joist. This makes a big difference in the vulnerability of the rim joist to moisture accumulation. For more information on the beneficial effect of drywall in preventing this type of moisture problem, see "Condensation on Wall Sheathing During Construction."

      1. Tyler Keniston | | #10

        Thanks Martin, that makes sense...
        though I've never thought of the floor assembly (between the joists and where the rim is) as being necessarily airtight unless extra care was taken. Assuming 2 story.
        My assumption being that first-story ceiling drywall may not have been made air-tight and second-story floor/sub-floor may not be airtight (especially if older house with board sub).

        But I'm imagining the premise is that even if not completely air-tight, its better off than the exposed first story rim. And additionally basements can be more humid.

        I should really peruse the literature on vapor retarders with exterior insulation, but if I recall correctly, for a wall with adequate exterior R-value, it's still recommended to have a class III retarder on the interior? If so (and I recall some debate on this maybe?), would this recommendation hold for the rim joist area?
        (unfortunately that would prove a pain to add something like that to each bay).

        1. GBA Editor
          Martin Holladay | | #11

          Tyler,
          If your rigid foam is thick enough, there is no reason to add an additional Class III vapor retarder on the interior.

          For one thing, your rigid foam is already either a vapor retarder or a vapor barrier. And even if you add a fiberglass batt on the interior side of the rigid foam, the rigid foam will never get cold enough to allow moisture accumulation -- assuming that your rigid foam is thick enough, and assuming that your fiberglass batt isn't unreasonably thick.

  4. Expert Member
    Malcolm Taylor | | #7

    One variation not touched on is insetting the rim-joist and using a continuous band of rigid insulation on the exterior. This has the added benefit of reducing thermal bridging at the floor joists.

    The standard detail in Canada where poly is still the most common air/vapour barrier, is using batt insulation and bedding a square of poly in acoustical sealant in each joist bay - which it time consuming, messy and hard to get right.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #8

      Malcolm,
      Although I didn't explicitly describe that technique, I noted (in the section under the heading "Can rim joists be insulated on the exterior?") that installing rigid foam on the exterior of a rim joist is "an approach which is superior in all respects to interior insulation." So I agree with you -- exterior rigid foam is a great way to go.

      1. Expert Member
        Malcolm Taylor | | #9

        Martin,

        The two caveats I'd add are that reducing the bearing of the wall above may cause problems, and adding foam on the exterior always comes with the risk of pest intrusions. Detailing my own house that way was the catalyst for a year long battle with carpenter ants.

      2. Fred Frasch | | #67

        Hello Martin and others,
        My build falls into this category. Climate zone 5, 1.5" exterior rigid foam extending down to sill plate. For convenience, I've considered spray foam on the interior to meet target R. Is this risky? I have just a thin foam seal between concrete foundation and sill. Would DIY foam be safe or should I stick with fluffy stuff ( mineral fiber)?
        Thank you for your invaluable contributions,
        Fred

  5. Mark Walker | | #12

    After cutting polyiso to fit between the joists, how is it held in place? Is spray foaming it enough to keep it tight to the rim?

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #13

      Mark,
      Re-read the article. I wrote, "The easiest way to hold rigid foam in place is to secure the foam to the rim joist with a couple of cap nails."

      1. Timothy Radsick | | #39

        A method that works better for me is to use site-built "cap screws": same thing, but with a Spax-type torx head screw swapped for the nail. I shoot for a 1/4" penetration into wood.

        Easy to install, snugs up the rigid foam nicely to the rim joist, easy to remove and reuse. I put a piece of 1/2" foam on as a crush block under the cap, put a tiny smear of foam adhesive/caulk on the back of the rigid foam. Once everything sets up, I remove the cap screw and seal the hole.

        Why this way? (1) my poor nailing skills bent way to many 2-1/2" cap screws, and (2) in retrofits with existing framed up basement walls, access is limited.

        1. GBA Editor
          Martin Holladay | | #40

          Timothy,
          I've used cap screws too (aluminum roofing buttons and ordinary drywall screws, in my case).

  6. Expert Member
    Malcolm Taylor | | #14

    Although it upsets the regular sequence of construction, the easiest time to install the foam between the joists, and seal three of the four edges, is before the subfloor is installed. It also makes it much simpler to create continuity between the insulation at the floor joists, and that on the crawlspace or basement walls below.

  7. Ryan Mount | | #15

    Hi Martin,

    Great article. One thought that came to mind while reading the section about letting the rim joist/mud sill breathe while covering the interior with spray foam is to avoid the use of vapour impermeable products to seal the joint between the foundation and sheathing. It is common where I live in Canada to seal this joint with Blueskin SA if there is masonry going up. Do you have a take on this?

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #16

      Ryan,
      If I understand correctly, you're asking about what product to use on the exterior of the house to seal potential air leaks between the bottom course of the wall sheathing and the concrete foundation. Is that correct?

      First of all, using tape at this seam is optional. A high-quality gasket or sill seal product under the mudsill, along with a bead of adhesive between the mudsill and the bottom of the sheathing, may be all you need.

      If you need a tape that seals the seam between plywood or OSB sheathing and concrete, many builders use Tescon Vana, which has a vapor permeance of 8 perms. (In other words, it allows some outward drying.)

      All of that said, the tape used to seal this seam is usually not very wide -- it might cover only 2 or three inches of the sheathing. The rim joist can still dry out to the exterior -- even if you choose a tape that isn't very vapor-permeable -- since the plywood or OSB sheathing is somewhat vapor-permeable, and since almost all brands of housewrap are also vapor-permeable.

  8. Ryan Mount | | #17

    Hi Martin,

    Thanks for the reply. I was just curious to know if there are recommendations to avoid using a vapour impermeable product there. It is an area prone to water damage and the ability to dry would be essential especially if using closed cell on the inside. I suppose if it is only an inch or 2 wide it won't make much of a difference.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #18

      Ryan,
      In theory, any tape used on the exterior side of wall sheathing should be vapor-permeable -- and any builder who wants to choose vapor-permeable tape can do so.

      Clearly, installing vapor-impermeable peel-and-stick over a substantial percentage of the exterior side of your wall sheathing would create a wrong-side vapor barrier, and could lead to moisture problems. But the use of 4-inch wide tape or even 6-inch wide tape -- even vapor-impermeable tape -- at sheathing seams (or at the seam between the bottom course of the siding and the foundation) almost never causes problems, because any accumulating moisture can wick sideways and evaporate from the exterior face of the nearby wall sheathing.

  9. Richard Hertz | | #19

    What about the use of liquid air sealing membrane applied to each joist opening coupled with air permeable insulation? I have some leftover Roxul and am thinking about placing it over something like 475’s Visconn painted/sprayed around all sides of the opening. Thanks!

    Richard

  10. Expert Member
    Carl Seville | | #20

    Martin - I just ran across a proposed amendment to the Georgia IECC from the pest control commission forbidding spray foam on rim joists. It will be interesting to see where it goes.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #21

      Carl,
      Thanks for alerting readers to the news.

  11. Toley Tillman | | #22

    Hi Martin. I used 1" rigid foam to insulate my rim joists, with spray foam sealer in the gaps around the rigid foam. As I researched this more, I understand that I likely should have used 2" rigid foam (climate zone 6a). Can I add another layer of the rigid foam (as I have some leftover)? Because the canned spray foam I sealed the edges with isn't uniform, the second layer of rigid foam won't neatly fit against the existing if I do go that route. If I add a second piece, and seal that, there will likely be a space between the two...does that matter? Thanks in advance.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #25

      Toley,
      You have two choices -- either of which will allow the second layer of rigid foam to sit tightly against the first layer of rigid foam. Either (a) trim back the excess cured spray foam with a knife before adding the second layer of rigid foam, or (b) cut the rectangles of the second layer of rigid foam to be small enough to fit between the irregular spray foam, and then seal the perimeter of the second layer with more spray foam.

      1. Toley Tillman | | #26

        Thank you for the suggestions..much appreciated! In one of the diagrams above, it shows some horizontal section of concrete at the top of the wall before the sill plate. My wall has only about a half inch of horizontal concrete. Would you advise spray foam for this area and if so, does it makes sense to use the fire blocking foam? Thank you in advance.

  12. user-7622516 | | #23

    Are you saying that it’s ok to only have rigid insulation covering the rim joist on the exterior, without any vapor barrier. I have this option on the second floor rim joist.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #24

      User-7622516,
      There are no code requirements for interior vapor barriers -- only a requirement, for certain types of wall assemblies, for an interior vapor retarder (a less stringent layer than a vapor barrier) in cold climates.

      That said, walls or rim joists with an adequately thick layer of exterior rigid foam never require an interior vapor retarder.

      Moreover, rigid foam is already a vapor retarder.

      For more information on this issues, see these articles:

      "Do I Need a Vapor Retarder?"

      "Calculating the Minimum Thickness of Rigid Foam Sheathing"

  13. Sam S | | #27

    Knowing the challenge associated with cutting tight fitting rigid insulation pieces to fit against the rim, I picked up a Manix HCM-2S hotwire foam cutter to try and improve accuracy. I picked this unit because it has a large enough bed to accommodate most joist bay widths I encounter. The benefit compared to a table saw is that the hotwire can be used to make quick scribe adjustments to the foam without involving another tool.

    I trialed it on 3-inch XPS and it struggles even at full power. The cut lags and catches, reducing accuracy. I was hoping that the fit would be tight enough to just install with a rasp and some caulk to seal, but it's not quite there.

    I think working with a thinner material (1 or 1.5-inch XPS) and then gluing the sheets together with 3m 78 or similar adhesives may work better, but I haven't had a chance to try that yet. I'm using XPS because l couldn't find large EPS sheets locally on short notice (working on that issue as well).

  14. greenhouse437 | | #28

    I had heard that such foam insulation close to the ground will attract termites or carpenter ants. Have you experienced this?

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #29

      Greenhouse,
      For more information on this topic, see "If Ants Like Rigid Foam, Should We Stop Using It?"

  15. George Smith | | #30

    Hi Martin,

    Some of my floor joists extend up to 2ft beyond my foundation, they overhang. I assume that, ideally, the cavity is spray foamed all the way to the sill plate and then down the inside foundation wall.

    What is the ideal way to spray foam a deep cavity and insure proper application?

    I've had one contractor tell me he would need to remove the soffit+osb and spray the overhang from exterior to be able to spray the underside of the floor. That would mean he couldnt spray the bottom of the cavity though.

    Another contractor told me no problem and that he could spray the whole cavity from the inside of the house. I'm a little worried the lack of visibility would limit the quality of application.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #31

      George,
      Spray foam is one option, but it's not the only option. For more information on insulating cantilevered floors, see this article: "Insulating a Wood-Framed Floor Assembly."

      1. George Smith | | #32

        Martin,

        Due to some time constraints with this project, I was planning on having the walls and rim joists done in one go.

        I suppose I could fill the deep cavities with rigid foam + spray foam before the contractor gets there leaving the crew with a shallower cavity to fill. Is it wise to combine both methods?

        The product they use is the AIRMETIC SOYA by Demilec although i'm not sure it's the HFO version

        1. GBA Editor
          Martin Holladay | | #34

          George,
          Airmetic Soya seems to be one of Demilec's brand names for use in Quebec -- online information is all in French. "Airmétic Soya est une mousse de polyuréthane giclée à cellules fermées" -- in other words, "Airmétic Soya is a closed-cell spray polyurethane foam."

          Only you can decide which combination of insulation to use. The key points are (a) air sealing is essential, and (b) if you are using a fluffy insulation like fiberglass or mineral wool, air sealing work must happen first, before insulation is installed.

  16. DavidSilva | | #33

    I’ve heard bad things about latex caulk in that it shrinks over time. For cut and cobbling rigid foam for applications like this, what is recommended for caulk/sealant?

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #35

      David,
      Either a polyurethane or silicone caulk will last longer (and therefore do a better job of air sealing) than latex painter's caulk.

      1. DavidSilva | | #36

        Thanks Martin. I’ll check those out.

  17. Josh Broome | | #37

    Martin you answer more questions than I think is humanly possible! Love the articles and analysis, really helps!

    On to my question. I am planning a basement remodel in a house which employs the same detail as your first picture of the band board/mudsill/floor joists. I am currently planning on having the floor joist cavities at the band board area sprayed along with the walls of the basement with closed cell. I was also planning on doing 1" all the way up on all the cinderblock walls and would like to tie that right into the band board spray to have a complete thermal barrier with no bridges. I would then build a 2x4 wall inside that in the basement and insulate that with fiberglass batts.

    My question is: how can you keep a solid foam barrier from the floor of the basement to the top of the floor joists and still provide fire-blocking? Only way I see to do it is by bridging the 2x4 wall to the cinderblock with 3/4 ply or other approved block at the top plate but that would break my foam layer. Also on the cinderblock basement wall in the other direction, horizontal, blocking that 1" area between the wall cavity and the cinderblock wall would make a thermal bridge in the foam.

    Thanks!

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #38

      J. Midway,
      You can frame the 2x4 wall before the spray foam contractor is invited to the house. Once the 2x4 wall is framed -- remember to leave a gap of at least 1 inch between the concrete block wall and the stud wall -- and the fireblocking is installed, the spray foam can be installed on either side of the fireblocking.

      The attached image shows the fireblocking detail. (Click on the image to enlarge.)
      [Image credit: Journal of Light Construction]

      1. Josh Broome | | #41

        Thanks, that makes sense. I was planning to do it that way but get alittle carried away with thermal bridging at times. That connection of the 3/4 ply from the floor joists to 2x4 walls with won't make that much of a difference, the joists are connecting either way.

        In this scenario is fire blocking required in the opposite orientation preventing fire horizontally? Like sistering a 3/4 inch beside one of the wall studs and butting it against the cinderblock? Hate to obstruct the insulation layer

      2. B Mac | | #53

        If the joists are perpendicular to the rim joist(s) you are going to fill with spray foam, the image works and I can see how the contractor can work around the fireblocking. However if the walls are perpendicular to the rim joists, I do not see how the spray foam contractor can can access the rim unless they drill though the joists. Is that what they have to do?

        1. GBA Editor
          Martin Holladay | | #54

          B. Mac,
          You have used the word "perpendicular" twice, and at least one instance of the word was probably mistaken -- I think you meant to write "parallel" in the second instance. You are right that when the joists are parallel to the rim joist, access the the area is sometimes difficult. Either plan ahead or drill some holes.

          1. Patrick Lee | | #74

            With the rim joists that are parallel to the joists and sprayed foam, do you need either 1) thermal barrier (no if less than 3.25 inch?) -- but what if it's already thicker than 3.25 inch? and 2) horizontal fireblock?

          2. GBA Editor
            Martin Holladay | | #75

            Patrick,
            If the gap that needs to be insulated is wider than 3.25 inches -- in other words, if after insulating there is more than a 3.25-inch-wide strip of exposed spray foam -- then you would need a thermal barrier like 1/2-inch drywall on the interior side of the spray foam.

            I'm not an expert on fire blocks, but in general the need for a fire block applies to stud wall spaces. If there is a stud wall under the spray foam you're describing, then fire block requirements apply. When in doubt, talk to your local building official to determine local requirements.

  18. kdodson6 | | #42

    Hot/humid climate 3a (South Carolina)..crawlspace w/moisture barrier, unfinished 2nd floor (plan to finish 1450sqft), & it’s a modular home. I’m sorry to beat a dead horse. I would like to know if spray foaming the perimeter of a rim/band joist would be as advantageous from an air sealing perspective as insulating the entire area(s) of each rim joist w/spray/rigid foam. Why not just do the perimeter(s)? How does air pass through wood if it has no cracks to pass through? Thank you for the articles and comments—I am learning a lot here.

    Also, would it be wise to insulate the married sections of the modular joists in a similar fashion (I’ve foamed the crack between the married joists at the bottom).

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #43

      K. Dodson,
      If all you are doing is air sealing, focus on the cracks. But if you care about R-value, you need to have a layer of insulation that covers the entire rim joist. In South Carolina, the building code requires above-grade walls to be insulated to at least R-13 -- so that's a good minimum target for the R-value of your rim joist insulation.

      1. kdodson6 | | #44

        Martin,

        Thank you for the reply. I got some reclaimed rigid foam that is used for roofing. It is not foil faced, but rather a polyiso with a fibrous dark colored covering. It is used for roofs. (R-Max MultiMax FA-G3) 2.5” R15.

        I’ve read a lot of your articles’ comments about covering with drywall afterward.

        I sincerely appreciate your time. I have so many questions.

      2. kdodson6 | | #45

        Also sir, I was concerned about the exterior of said rim joist as well. I have crawled the crawlspace a lot now and I’ve done my best to air seal electrical/plumbing/HVAC register penetrations.

        The exterior cladding is vinyl siding and at the very bottom of the siding, I can see the mud sill connected to the brick crawl foundation. Can a product be used to successfully close that gap? I’ve read about gaskets but this is existing construction. Could tape or a form of caulking work there?

        I guess I’m confused for several reasons, but I feel air sealing needs to occur both interior AND exterior for it to be effective. I would think air/water could run through the mud sill seam and even though it’s foamed from the inside, air would still be able to travel up. Am I off in my thinking?

        1. GBA Editor
          Martin Holladay | | #46

          K. Dodson,
          Q. "The exterior cladding is vinyl siding and at the very bottom of the siding, I can see the mud sill connected to the brick crawl foundation. Can a product be used to successfully close that gap?"

          A. Any gap between the mudsill and the foundation can be sealed with a high-quality caulk. Note, however, that you don't want to caulk the gap between the vinyl siding and the mudsill. That gap should be allowed to drain.

          Q. "I feel air sealing needs to occur both interior AND exterior for it to be effective. I would think air/water could run through the mud sill seam and even though it’s foamed from the inside, air would still be able to travel up. Am I off in my thinking?"

          A. In theory, all you need is one air barrier. If all you have is an interior air barrier, and the air barrier is perfect, your air sealing work is done. That said, perfection is rare, and many builders prefer the approach you suggest -- sealing envelope leaks on both sides. For more information on this topic, see this article: "One Air Barrier or Two?"

          Your concerns about water entry are a little different from your concerns about air sealing. It's always a good idea to prevent water entry, but the usual way to prevent water entry is to use flashing -- and flashing doesn't have to be airtight. It just has to prevent water entry. For more information on flashing, see "All About Flashing."

          The normal way to prevent water entry at the gap you're talking about (the gap between the mudsill and the foundation) is with your water-resistive barrier (usually asphalt felt or housewrap). Hopefully, your house has a water-resistive barrier. If it doesn't, your house isn't up to modern standards -- but it may still be OK, especially if the house has adequate roof overhangs. For more information on WRBs, see "All About Water-Resistive Barriers."

          1. kdodson6 | | #47

            Martin, thank you SO much! I appreciate it. As for the rigid foam, I’ve attached a picture of the faced-on-both-sides pieces I plan to use. I also took a picture of the marriage joint in the middle of the home. Does this count as rim-joist space as well?

  19. Derek Bredl | | #48

    I understand that EPS is a 'greener' choice but I have read that EPS is not as good as XPS for air and water vapor sealing as it is not a 'true' closed cell foam? Isn't that a really important issue to be considering with insulating rim joists? Will I need a lot more EPS compared to XPS to achieve the same levels of air and water vapor 'barrier-ness'?

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #49

      User-7634665,
      EPS and XPS are both air barriers. When it is brand new, XPS has a slightly higher R-value per inch (about R-5 per inch for XPS, versus about R-4 per inch for EPS) -- but over time (a few decades), the R-value of XPS gradually drops to the same level as EPS when new. The R-value of EPS does not change over time.

      EPS is somewhat more vapor-permeable than XPS, but the difference in vapor permeance has no consequences for performance when it comes to rim joist insulation. One inch of unfaced EPS has a vapor permeance of 2.0 to 5.8 perms. One inch of XPS has a vapor permeance of 1.1.

      For more information on these issues, see "Choosing Rigid Foam."

      1. Derek Bredl | | #51

        Thanks!

    2. Expert Member
      Dana Dorsett | | #50

      >" EPS is not as good as XPS for air and water vapor sealing as it is not a 'true' closed cell foam"

      EPS is indeed a true closed cell foam.

      Neither EPS nor XPS is a true vapor barrier (and that's usually a GOOD thing.)

      The higher vapor permeance of EPS relative to XPS is largely due to the intersitial spaces between the macroscopic beads. That is easily solved by facers if the stackup really calls for it. Where a true vapor barrier is needed, foil or plastic faced EPS (or foil faced polyiso) is more than an order of magnitude more vapor tight than XPS...

      ...and an order of magnitude LESS damaging to the environment:

      https://materialspalette.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/CSMP-Insulation_090919-01.png

      This isn't subtle- there is no argument in a "green building" discussion for using XPS- there is always a better, greener (and usually cheaper) solution.

      In Europe XPS blown with CO2 has been available for quite some time, which has about the same environmental impact of EPS. It's labeled R/inch is the same as EPS of similar density, but it's vapor retardency is lower, about the same as HFC blown XPS in the US, and has somewhat higher load pressure ratings.

  20. Matt Fogal | | #52

    Can someone give me additional guidance for insulating the rim joist? I live in Zone 5 and my rim joists only have fiberglass batts. The image in the article shows 2 inches of rigid foam and then optional cavity insulation, but does not indicate where the 1/2 inch drywall thermal barrier should be installed for this scenario. Do I cover the rigid foam with the drywall but then leave the fiberglass exposed, or cover both? And if I'm supposed to be covering both, how would I prevent the fiberglass from being compressed in this scenario? Thanks in advance for your guidance.

  21. CarsonB | | #55

    it looks like you can use mineral wool or other types of fire resistant insulation instead of drywall to cover foam. So if you are planning on doing rigid foam -> insulation in your rim joist and use a mineral wool batt, you can skip the drywall or thermax. Given that the only thermax I can find online is listed at $75 per sheet for 2", it may make more sense to go this route for the whole foundation wall as well. I'm not sure the best way to attach it though if you want to use the fluffier interior insulation and not the more rigid exterior mineral wool. I guess just screws and washers and don't care about over compression.

    section R316.5.4:
    The foam plastic insulation has been tested in accordance with Section R316.6 or the foam plastic insulation is protected against ignition using one of the following ignition barrier materials:
    11/2-inch-thick (38 mm) mineral fiber insulation;
    1/4-inch-thick (6.4 mm) wood structural panels;
    3/8-inch (9.5 mm) particleboard;
    1/4-inch (6.4 mm) hardboard;
    3/8-inch (9.5 mm) gypsum board; or
    Corrosion-resistant steel having a base metal thickness of 0.016 inch (0.406 mm).

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #56

      Carson,
      Thanks for your comment. My understanding is that interior rigid foam (other than Thermax) on rim joists need to be covered by a thermal barrier, not an ignition barrier. (For a thorough discussion of the difference between a thermal barrier and an ignition barrier, see "Thermal Barriers and Ignition Barriers for Spray Foam.")

      The part of the code you quote (section R316.5.4) covers ignition barriers, not thermal barriers. (Ignition barriers are less stringent than thermal barriers.) Note that ignition barriers are legal if your basement spaces aren’t used for storage, and as long as entry to the space is made only for repairs, maintenance, or service of utilities. Few basements fall into this category.

      A sufficiently thick layer of mineral wool insulation can, indeed, be used as an ignition barrier -- but, to the best of my knowledge, it can't be used as a thermal barrier.

      When in doubt, talk to your local code official to determine local interpretation of these code requirements.

      1. CarsonB | | #59

        thanks Martin, nice and confusing :) Since my "basement" is really just a small utility room carved into the crawlspace I might actually meet that use criteria, though I have no way of keeping future homeowners from shoving random stuff down there if I ever move out. It does appear that two types of 2" rockwool from roxul meet the "thermal barrier" criteria, comfortboard 80 and roxul safe 45. I'm guessing these are more expensive than standard and probably not worth the additional R value over drywall. I'm not sure how much r value mineral wool would add if not covered anyway.

        https://p-cdn.rockwool.com/siteassets/o2-rockwool/documentation/technical-bulletins/residential/thermal-barrier-technical-bulletin.pdf?f=20180618130807

        1. GBA Editor
          Martin Holladay | | #60

          Carson,
          Thanks for providing the link to the Rockwool document ("Use of ROCKWOOL stone wool as a Thermal and Ignition Barrier"). I was unaware that Rockwool had gone to the trouble of having some of its mineral wool products evaluated as thermal barriers. Evidently these tested products have been shown to be equivalent to 1/2-inch drywall when evaluated as thermal barriers -- which was news to me.

          The code documents don't list mineral wool insulation products as thermal barriers -- but as long a legitimate laboratory has shown these products to perform in a way that is equivalent to 1/2-inch drywall, they qualify as thermal barriers. That was news to me.

          1. CarsonB | | #65

            martin, R15 is required in my cz. Would 1.5 - 2" polyiso + 1.75" of mineral wool meet this requirement and be safe from condensation? would the uncovered 1.75" of mineral wool lose most rvalue?

          2. GBA Editor
            Martin Holladay | | #66

            Carson,
            Q. "R-15 is required in my climate zone. Would 1.5 – 2″ of polyiso + 1.75″ of mineral wool meet this requirement?"

            A. 1.5 inch of polyiso has an R-value of about R-10, and 1.75 inch of mineral wool has an R-value of about R-7. Add them up and you get R-17, so the answer is yes.

            Q. "Would this combination be safe from condensation?"

            A. Yes.

  22. Slav Pakhnyuk | | #57

    Does it make sense to insulate and seal a the rim joist in a vented crawl space? I have a framing crew starting in a couple of weeks and planning out the insulation and air sealing details. Any help would be highly appreciated.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #58

      Slav,
      Yes, you'll need rim joist insulation. In fact, you'll want to install insulation between the floor joists -- which is to say that the entire floor assembly (the ceiling of your crawl space) will need to be insulated.

      The alternative would be to leave the floor assembly uninsulated and to insulate the walls of your crawl space instead. But in that case, you would be building an unvented crawl space rather than a vented crawl space.

      1. Slav Pakhnyuk | | #61

        Martin, here in the Pacific Northwest, we mostly build homes with vented crawl spaces, with the joists insulated using R-30 fiberglass batts.

        I haven't seen anyone insulate the rim joists and I plan on doing that this build as long as it makes sense. The reason I started questioning it is I'm having a difficult time understanding why it makes sense to pay attention to air seal the gaps in the rim joist, while at the same time you have open vents (sometimes year round) into that same space. Does it makes sense because it limits air leakage when the vents are covered (if covered) for winter time?

        1. Expert Member
          Malcolm Taylor | | #62

          Slav,

          I know vented crawlspaces work in the PNW, in that they don't cause the problems you see in most other climates, but I'm not sure that make them a good idea. Insulating and air-sealing the underside of the floor, leaving a huge area of the building unconditioned where services are commonly run, relying on moist exterior air to dry the space without heating it to reduce the dew p0int - are all not great strategies. Recently your PNW neighbours to the north have stopped building vented crawlspaces, and it might be time for builders down there to consider d0ing the same?

          If you do decide to go the vented route, the proper way to vent the crawlspace would be to box in a short area of the rim-joist next to the vents with rigid foam to direct the air to the crawlspace below, while still insulating the entire joist bays, including those at the perimeter.

          1. Slav Pakhnyuk | | #63

            Malcolm, I understand what the pitfalls are of a vented crawlspace and I completely agree with you. That being said, this build has already been designed and permitted. We broke ground on Wednesday and the foundation forms are currently being set.

            I'm looking to make the best of the situation and want to try to the rim joist insulation approach. I like the idea to box the short area to direct the air. Would this still be beneficial if the floor insulation between the span of the joists in the vented crawlspace is just exposed fiberglass batts?

        2. Slav Pakhnyuk | | #68

          Martin, any advice on this?

          1. GBA Editor
            Martin Holladay | | #69

            Slav,
            Q. "I'm having a difficult time understanding why it makes sense to pay attention to air seal the gaps in the rim joist, while at the same time you have open vents (sometimes year round) into that same space."

            A. If you are planning to have a vented crawl space, you'll need to insulate the floor assembly above the crawl space. This article tells you how to do that: "Insulating a Wood-Framed Floor Assembly."

            If you insulate between the floor joists with a fluffy insulation like fiberglass or mineral wool, you'll need an air barrier on all six sides of the insulation. (If air is blowing through your insulation, the insulation won't be very effective.) So there will be an air barrier -- perhaps OSB, perhaps plywood, perhaps rigid foam -- between the fluffy insulation and the crawl space.

            The rim joist will be within this insulation. You don't necessarily need to insulate the rim joist with rigid foam or spray foam -- after all, you'll probably have fiberglass or mineral wool insulation against the rim joist -- but you certainly need to air seal the rim joist area before insulating. You don't want any cold air blowing through the fiberglass, because that type of air movement robs the insulation material of its R-value.

            It's acceptable (sort of) to vent the crawl space because the crawl space is outside of the home's thermal envelope. But having an air leak in the middle of your insulation is very bad. That is precisely where you don't want any air movement.

          2. Slav Pakhnyuk | | #72

            Thanks Martin. I’ll focus on air sealing the rim joist. If I don’t end up using rigid foam against the rim joist (since fluffy insulation will be against it anyway), what do you recommend I use for perimeter air sealing?

            Canned spray foam, acoustical sealant or caulking?

          3. GBA Editor
            Martin Holladay | | #73

            Slav,
            Careful installation is more important than the type of material used. Narrower cracks usually get caulk or sealant -- choose a high-quality brand, not cheap latex painter's caulk -- and wider cracks usually get canned spray foam. But the attitude of the installer is what really differentiates a good job from a bad job.

  23. Expert Member
    Malcolm Taylor | | #64

    Slav,

    Nothing like someone giving you rant about something you already agree with huh ;)

    To get back to your original question: I'm not sure it makes sense to air-seal the rim joists either if your air-barrier is the subfloor above. I think boxing in near the vents is a good idea. It leaves almost all of the rim-joist in the same condition as the rest of the cavities, so the whole floor is then insulated. Ideally you would place a somewhat effective secondary air-barrier on the underside of the joists (and then it might make sense to air-seal the rim-joists), but that's probably too labour intensive with all the plumbing penetrations and strapping to be worthwhile.

  24. Will R | | #70

    Martin,

    I thought I had read somewhere in the q&a, that folks insulating an older home without a capillary break should consider EPS or Open cell spray foam to allow for more drying to the interior. I think it may have been another rim joist insulation article of yours where you refuted this (at least the open cell question)? Thank you for your time.

    1. GBA Editor
      Martin Holladay | | #71

      Will,
      The article on this page includes my recommendations concerning older homes without a capillary break under the mudsill. In almost all situations, especially in colder climates, the origin of damaging moisture -- moisture that might lead to mold or rim-joist rot -- is indoor air, so you don't want to use open-cell spray foam. Open-cell spray foam will allow indoor moisture to reach the cold rim joist by diffusion. So stick with closed-cell spray foam.

      EPS will work -- it's enough of a vapor retarder to avoid problems -- but the reasons you might choose EPS has nothing to do with "allowing drying to the interior."

  25. bloveonbass | | #76

    Hello,
    I have web style floor trusses. I can use rigid foam simply enough between the trusses but how do you recommend the outer 2 trusses. Can I glue the foam to the side of the outer trusses or would that trapped air inside the trusses cause problems? I imagine I could cut the foam at all of the angles and glue it to the outer sheathing but I didn't know how feasible that would be to get all of those angled cuts sealed.
    Thank you for your help!
    Brandon

  26. Doug McEvers | | #77

    Typically those outer trusses are non load bearing as they sit on top of the wall and are framed 16" OC. They are not triangulated like the load bearing floor trusses. I would cut rigid foam to fit and seal the joints.

    1. bloveonbass | | #78

      Thanks for the reply. Unfortunately the outer trusses on my house are identical to all the other ones having all of the angles. Would you still suggest that I attempt to cut all those angles in order to get the foam against the outer sheathing?
      Thanks again!

      1. GBA Editor
        Martin Holladay | | #79

        Brandon,
        You can buy a two-component spray foam kit to insulate this type of joist.

        1. bloveonbass | | #80

          Thanks Martin! I’ll have to check into that.

  27. Davin E. | | #81

    CZ 5b with a conditioned basement -

    I have stumbled on the attached image (originally saw the method in Bruce Harley's book). Showing running the rigid foam all the way from a basement wall to the subfloor. Notching around the floor joists.

    This method seems like it would be a little easier to install with less to seal (better air sealing).

    Are there any issues with this method.. for appropriate climate zones that are using an interior air barrier...instead of the cutting out the rigid rectangles and placing them tight to inside of rim joist?

    PDF image comes from: https://www.njcleanenergy.com/files/file/Residential%20Programs/NJ%20ENERGY%20STAR%20Homes/NJ_5-08-08.pdf

Log in or become a member to post a comment.

Related

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |